Updates and Results Talks and Posters Advice Ideas Important Figures Write-Ups Outreach How-To Funding Opportunities GENETIS
  GENETIS, Page 3 of 13  ELOG logo
  ID Datedown Author Subject
  203   Mon Mar 20 13:35:25 2023 Amyinfo on format for PUEO antenna files

William Luszczak  1:30 PM

This is the directory with the current PUEO antenna data files: https://github.com/PUEOCollaboration/pueoSim/tree/main/data/antennas. Each type of antenna will need several files:

  • vv_0 and hh_0 describe the on axis v and h pol gain as a function of frequency. Gain is listed as a multiplicative factor (not in dB, if I'm remembering correctly)
  • hv_0 and vh_0 describe the on axis cross polarization gain
  • vv_az and hh_az describe the off-axis gain via multiplicative factors of the boresight gain. These are currently listed as a function of frequency for reference angles of 0,10,20,30,40,50,60,70,80, and 90 degrees, though we can always adjust the reference angles if needed.
  • vv_el and hh_el are similar to above, but for gain as a function of elevation angle instead of azimuthal angle.

So for example, the total vpol gain in a particular frequency bin for a signal incident at azimuthal angle az and elevation angle el would be vv_0(f)*vv_az(f, az)*vv_el(f, el)


New

1:31

We can also potentially adjust this if it would be more convenient for the GENETIS people to output antenna information in a different format (or at different reference angles or whatever). The important thing is that the boresight h, v, and cross pol gains are all defined, as well as the off-axis response (as a function of azimuth and elevation)

  202   Mon Mar 20 12:37:38 2023 AmyANITA/PUEO pictures

Here are some ANITA/PUEO pictures that I received from Christian Mike that might be helpful.  I include his descriptions as well.

The one with the black crates in the background is the  ANITA 1 and ANITA 2 form factor and the one in the anechoic chamber is the ANITA 3 and ANITA 4 form factor. I dimensioned out an ANITA 3/4 antenna, in CAD space, to give you a better idea of the ridge profile. The ANITA 1/2 CAD models we have, I found, are inaccurate.

Attached are images of the PUEO antenna array geometry. One image annotates the approximate locations of the Vpol feed with the top antenna feed as the origin.

 

 

 

 

Attachment 1: IMG_2362.jpg
IMG_2362.jpg
Attachment 2: IMG_2364.jpg
IMG_2364.jpg
Attachment 3: IMG_2365.jpg
IMG_2365.jpg
  201   Tue Mar 7 00:06:57 2023 Bryan ReynoldsRetroactive AREA update: January 18, 2022 AREA run- No linear freq. dependence test w/ increased NPop

The following is a run summary of an AREA test using 100 individuals per generation, without the linear frequency dependence on the gain, with the frequency fixed (i.e. the same gain pattern is produced for all frequencies). This run was a preliminary test of the AREA algorithm with a larger NPop (100 individuals per generation) after seeing promising results in the previous test that only used 20 individuals per generation. The percentages of selection methods/operators used attempted to mimic the optimal percentages used for the PAEA Bicone Loop, but because the algorithms do not set these in the same manner, these are highly unlikely to be the best percentages to use. The results show a very quick plateau in fitness score with a loss in diversity of solutions after a low number of generations, potentially meaning that a poor breakdown of selection methods/operators was chosen. This result seems to underscore the need for a test loop-style optimization for AREA to determine the best breakdown of selection methods and operators to use for AREA.

Run details:

  • Run Type
    • AREA
  • Run Date
    • January 18, 2023
  • Run Name
    • 20230118breynoldsrun_noLinearDependAREATest_38RCO_2RM_58TCO_2TM_150000NNU_2Seeds
  • Why are we doing this run?
    • This test increased the number of individuals to 100 and attempted to mimic the percentages of selection methods and operators found to be optimal for the PAEA loop.
  • What is different about this run from the last?
    • The previous test showed slow/minimal evolution after ~12 generations, and it was speculated that this was due to a small NPop of 20 individuals. This test uses an increased NPop of 100 individuals.
  • Symmetric, asymmetric, linear, nonlinear (what order):
    • N/A
  • Number of individuals (NPOP):
    • 100
  • Number of neutrinos thrown in AraSim (NNT):
    • 300,000 Total (150,000 NNU x 2 Seeds)
  • Operatiors used (% of each):
    • 96% Cross-Over, 4% Mutation
  • Selection methods used (% of each):
    • 40% Roullette, 60% Tournament
  • Are we using the database?
    • N/A

 

Results:

  • Summary and comments on results
    • The fitness score quickly plaeaued and diversity of solutions was lost, potentially due to a unsuccessful choice of selection method and opterator percentages.
    • An important future step is to work with Ryan to create a test loop optimization for the AREA algorithm, as it is written differently in how it is passed selection method and operator percentages and requires its own optimization to find the optimal ratios of these. (Work on creating a test loop optimization for AREA is currently underway).

 

EDIT 4/10/23
Re-uploading gain pattern associated with most fit individual from this run

 

Attachment 1: 20230201_singleFreqTest_100NPop_fitnessPlot_10Gens.PNG
20230201_singleFreqTest_100NPop_fitnessPlot_10Gens.PNG
Attachment 2: 20230410_AREA_mostFitIndivReUpload_singleFreqTest.PNG
20230410_AREA_mostFitIndivReUpload_singleFreqTest.PNG
  200   Mon Mar 6 23:25:12 2023 Bryan ReynoldsRetroactive AREA update: December 26, 2022 AREA run- No linear freq. dependence test

The following is a run summary of the AREA test without the linear frequency dependence on the gain, with the frequency fixed (i.e. the same gain pattern is produced for all frequencies). This run was a preliminary test of the AREA algorithm after fixing long-standing errors in the algorithm and finding that the initial constaints implemented did not work with the frequency dependence on gain. Results from this run did show a "proof-of-concept" that the AREA algorithm seems to evolve single frequencies in a promising way, however a low number of individuals may have stalled the evolution.

Run details:

  • Run Type
    • AREA
  • Run Date
    • December 26, 2022
  • Run Name
    • 20221226breynoldsrun_noLinearDependAREATest_8RCO_8RM_2TCO_2TM_30000NNU_10Seeds
  • Why are we doing this run?
    • We tested the AREA algorithm set to evolve at a single frequency in order to see if it would evolve a gain pattern at that frequency within the required constraints.
  • What is different about this run from the last?
    • This run only evolves gain patterns at a single frequency, allowing us to investigate the evolved gain patterns and check that the required constraints on the power conservation are met, without yet fixing the constraints function to work with the linear frequency dependence relationship. This is also the longest test run since the AREA algorithm was fixed and gotten into working order.
  • Symmetric, asymmetric, linear, nonlinear (what order):
    • N/A
  • Number of individuals (NPOP):
    • 20
  • Number of neutrinos thrown in AraSim (NNT):
    • 300,000 Total (30,000 NNU x 10 Seeds)
  • Operatiors used (% of each):
    • 50% Cross-Over, 50% Mutation
  • Selection methods used (% of each):
    • 80% Roullette, 20% Tournament
  • Are we using the database?
    • N/A

Results:

  • Summary and comments on results
    • The evolution appeared to be successful in that the most fit gain pattern found (attached) seems to make sense with our understanding of the underlying physics. Additionally, after inspecting the outputs, conservation of power was confirmed to be properly constrained. However, in the attached violin plot, the fitness score plateaued quickly and never evolved further, with the best individual coming in generation 12. This was speculated to be due to the small population used in this test (only 20 total individuals per generation).
Attachment 1: 20230109_singleFreqTest_fitnessPlot_update30Gens.PNG
20230109_singleFreqTest_fitnessPlot_update30Gens.PNG
Attachment 2: 20221229_singleFreqTest_overallBestIndiv_gen12Indiv17.PNG
20221229_singleFreqTest_overallBestIndiv_gen12Indiv17.PNG
  Draft   Mon Mar 6 00:07:32 2023 Dylan WellsCurrent Status of PUEO and To Do List for Hackathon

I went through the current PUEO Loop  and documented everything that still needs to be accomplished before we can run.

Everything is compiled in this Google Doc which I will paste the current version of below.

 

Current Loop Overview:

 

Part A:

Runs GA, need to implement most recent GA (easy)

 

Part B:

B1:

Enters PUEO freq into simulation_PEC.xmacro then cats in PUEO simulationPECmacroskeletons.

Will  need to update simulationPECmacroskeletons with XF script to simulate the Hpol and Vpol sides of the antenna separately.

The bash portion should be working.

 

B2:

Currently almost the same as the ARA version. Creates the output.xmacro and moves the uan files. Will most likely need to change to get files in PUEO/icemc format, ready for input into the conversion script.

 

Part C:

Runs conversion script XFintoPUEO.py

The Bash portion is complete. We will need simple modifications to XFintoPUEO.py depending on XF outputs.

 

Part D:

D1:

Changes setup file, runs IceMCCall_Array.sh batch job

Need make this batch job to change IceMC / PUEO to read in the correct files 

(vv_0_{gen}_{i}, hh_0_{gen}_{i}) for the antenna i in generation gen.

I’ve commented where this should go. The rest of the job should be complete

The debug mode for D1 might not work, but it shouldn’t be necessary to run. 

So, the bash portion should be able to run.

 

D2:

Currently confirms runs by looking at the number of files in the AraSimConfirmed directory and looks for specific AraSim errors. 

This line will need to be changed to count the output files for icemc/pueo.

Change the error detection to just resubmit the job or something similar as we aren’t yet familiar with icemc errors during runtime. 

 

Part E:

Runs the PUEO fitness function. Unfortunately, icemc doesn’t output error bars, so we will have to remake any plots reliant on that. Veffective is also the same as fitness score.

Currently it should be working with the basic needed plots for gain patterns and veffective scores. But, we should add some more cool, automatic plots. 

 

Part F:

The plotting software seems to be specific to ARA output, needs PUEO versions.


 

ASYM LOOP:

Should be working with PUEO as a switch


 

IMPORTANT ISSUES:

 

Find out how to simulate polarization in XF:

Modify the current XF model, can be found in PAS1960/dylanwells1629/testproject.xf

The current model has all 4 sides of the antenna connected. However, the actual antenna is basically 2 antennas, one hpol and one vpol, electrically disconnected from each other. So, adjacent parts shouldn’t be electrically connected like they currently are in the model. We might have to simulate the two models independently. The goal for this portion is to figure out how to split up the antenna in the xmacro, and how to either simulate hpol and vpol separately or how to get xf to output hpol and vpol gain patterns.

XF Cross - Polarization, constraints --Alex

 

Make IceMC / PUEO read in out input gain patterns 

Will need to modify Batch_Jobs/IceMCCallArray.sh to change icemc to read in the current gain files before running. You can find the conversion script in Antenna_Performance_Metric/XFintoPUEO.py and the batch job will be run in Loop_Parts/Part_D 

We need to change icemc / pueo to read in the correct gain files before running it.

This will involve changing the anitaBuildTool/components/icemc/anita.cc ReadGains function starting on line 1413 to read in vv_0_{gen}_{num}, hh_0_{gen}_{num} , etc. (Do this with PueoSim) -- Dylan

I’m not sure if you will need to recompile these functions before running the icemc executable again, so find that out too. (enter pueoBuolder/ just run make) --Dylan

 

Make PUEO plotting software

All of the current plotting software is found within Part_E and Part_F. Sadly, icemc does not output errors for the veffectives (at least not that I could find, maybe you can find it), so much of the Ara plotting software will not work with PUEO outputs. The fitness scores csv will be the same format as ARA’s, and veffectives will be the same as fitness scores for PUEO. Figure out how to change the existing ARA python plotting scripts or make new ones.  --Bryan

 

Find out how to run PEUOsim and document outputs

Currently the loop is working with icemc, but we want to use PUEOsim for the future. So, document installing it, running it, and the outputs. (inputs are the same as icemc) -- Dylan 

  198   Fri Feb 24 10:05:38 2023 Alex MPaper Symmetric Run for Reviewer

We began a new run for a symmetric bicone antenna. The purpose of this is to satisfy the most recent comments from the reviewer on the paper. We are using the same GA as for the paper with the same parameters. I will update this post soon with more details about this run. There is a run_details file attached, but please wait for me to update this post with more specifics as the version of the GA being used is less connected to the details presented in that file.

The data can be found here: /fs/ess/PAS1960/BiconeEvolutionOSC/BiconeEvolution/current_antenna_evo_build/XF_Loop/Evolutionary_Loop/Run_Outputs/2023_02_20_Symmetric_Run .

Attachment 1: run_details_2023_02_20_Symmetric_Run.txt
####### VARIABLES: LINES TO CHECK OVER WHEN STARTING A NEW RUN ###############################################################################################
RunName='2023_02_20_Symmetric_Run'      ## This is the name of the run. You need to make a unique name each time you run.
TotalGens=100                   ## number of generations (after initial) to run through
NPOP=50                         ## number of individuals per generation; please keep this value below 99
Seeds=10                        ## This is how many AraSim jobs will run for each individual## the number frequencies being iterated over in XF (Currectly only affects the output.xmacro loop)
FREQ=60                         ## the number frequencies being iterated over in XF (Currectly only affects the output.xmacro loop)
NNT=30000                       ## Number of Neutrinos Thrown in AraSim
exp=18                          ## exponent of the energy for the neutrinos in AraSim
ScaleFactor=1.0                 ## ScaleFactor used when punishing fitness scores of antennae larger than the drilling holes
GeoFactor=1                     ## This is the number by which we are scaling DOWN our antennas. This is passed to many files
num_keys=4                      ## how many XF keys we are letting this run use
database_flag=0                 ## 0 if not using the database, 1 if using the database
                                ## These next 3 define the symmetry of the cones.
RADIUS=0                        ## If 1, radius is asymmetric. If 0, radius is symmetric
LENGTH=0                        ## If 1, length is asymmetric. If 0, length is symmetric
ANGLE=0                         ## If 1, angle is asymmetric. If 0, angle is symmetric
CURVED=0                        ## If 1, evolve curved sides. If 0, sides are straight
A=0                             ## If 1, A is asymmetric
B=0                             ## If 1, B is asymmetric
SEPARATION=0                    ## If 1, separation evolves. If 0, separation is constant
NSECTIONS=1                     ## The number of chromosomes
DEBUG_MODE=0                    ## 1 for testing (ex: send specific seeds), 0 for real runs
                                ## These next variables are the values passed to the GA
REPRODUCTION=3                  ## Number (not fraction!) of individuals formed through reproduction
CROSSOVER=36                    ## Number (not fraction!) of individuals formed through crossover
MUTATION=25                     ## Probability of mutation (divided by 100)
SIGMA=6                         ## Standard deviation for the mutation operation (divided by 100)
ROULETTE=8                      ## Percent of individuals selected through roulette (divided by 10)
TOURNAMENT=2                    ## Percent of individuals selected through tournament (divided by 10)
RANK=0                          ## Percent of individuals selected through rank (divided by 10)
ELITE=0                         ## Elite function on/off (1/0)

#####################################################################################################################################################
  197   Mon Feb 20 12:33:20 2023 Dennis H. CalderonAraSim Simulations for Top 5 Antennas (12/2022) with Higher Stats

AraSim Simulations for Top 5 Antennas from 12/2022 Run with 3 million simulated events

Simulated using Arasim version currently used in GENETIS Loop

/fs/ess/PAS1960/BiconeEvolutionOSC/AraSim/
 

AraSim ROOT files stored in

/fs/ess/PAS1960/ROOT_Files_Higher_Stats/AraSim_Loop_122022/Feb_2023_Crazy_Sides/

Antennas simulated

  • Generation: 13, Individual: 84
  • Generation: 18, Individual: 89
  • Generation: 19, Individual: 96
  • Generation: 29, Individual: 87
  • Generation: 9, Individual: 50

 

Results

Antenna Total Events Triggered Events Weighted Events Effective Volume Effective Volume Error
13_84 2995982 40251 16058 5.71 0.035
18_89 3010000 40224 15963 5.65 0.035
19_96 3010000 39989 16034 5.68 0.031
29_87 3010000 40056 16049 5.68 0.034
9_50 3010000 40042 16057 5.69 0.034
ARA_Sym_Bicone_6in 3010000 36627 14334 5.08 0.032

 

Conclusion

Antenna from Generation 13 Individual 84 performed the best with these stats

Attachment 1: Crazy_Sides_Triggered_Event_Data.pdf
  196   Sun Feb 19 17:12:34 2023 Jack TillmanPhysics Plots - 9_50, 13_84, 18_89, 19_96, 29_87

Attached is a pdf of physics plots generated for the 9_50, 13_84, 18_89, 19_96, and 29_87 crazy sides individuals along with another containing information on the amount of triggered events and effective volumes for each individual. The crazy sides individuals were simulated for 3 million events using the same Arasim version as is currently in the loop.

Attachment 1: Feb2023_Physics_Plots_Powerpoint.pdf
Attachment 2: Crazy_Sides_Triggered_Event_Data.pdf
  195   Wed Feb 15 16:33:17 2023 Jacob WeilerpueoSim Input Files

Input File Format for pueoSim (Also ICEMC)

Frequency Range: From 200 MHz to 1500 MHz incrementing by 10 MHz steps

 

There are 8 different files that are required for pueoSim. They are:

vv_0: Max Gain at each Frequency, Vertical Polarization

hh_0: Max Gain at each Frequency, Horizontal Polarization

vh_0: Max Gain at each Frequency, Vertical to Horizontal Polarization

hv_0: Max Gain at each Frequency, Horizontal to Vertical Polarization

vv_el: Gain at Theta Angles [5, 10, 20, 30, 45, 90] for each Frequency, Vertical Polarization

vv_az: Gain at Phi Angles [5, 10, 20, 30, 45, 90] for each Frequency, Vertical Polarization

hh_el: Gain at Theta Angles [5, 10, 20, 30, 45, 90] for each Frequency, Horizontal Polarization

hh_az: Gain at Phi Angles [5, 10, 20, 30, 45, 90] for each Frequency, Horizontal Polarization

Currently XF doesn't output all the information we need to create all these files. The only files able to be made from current XF outputs are vv_0, vv_el, and vv_az. Once we have the correct XF Outputs, it shouldn't be too much of a hassle to fix the current translation code.

 

Format for each of the files are the same. One column is Frequency (Hz) and the other is Gain. Attached are example files vv_0 and vv_el to visually see the format, though the frequency range is the current ARA range and not the final PUEO range as I am using ARA data to make these files. The files are named vv_0 (no .txt or .csv or any extension) and vv_el

 

Link to Google Doc with this information: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1iRUF6hIEyQfMK0LL21caRuHPgXYP30ZdkSkFv_-Y8R0/edit

Attachment 1: vv_0_1
8.33e+07 2.11822 
1.00e+08 0.9436538 
1.17e+08 1.205556 
1.33e+08 2.149637 
1.50e+08 2.729287 
1.67e+08 2.619639 
1.83e+08 2.532374 
2.00e+08 2.289813 
2.17e+08 2.406259 
2.33e+08 2.442176 
2.50e+08 2.628373 
2.67e+08 2.359219 
2.83e+08 1.761219 
3.00e+08 1.502431 
3.17e+08 2.106109 
3.33e+08 2.71283 
3.50e+08 3.247887 
3.67e+08 3.524175 
3.83e+08 3.615199 
4.00e+08 3.448137 
4.17e+08 3.003371 
4.33e+08 2.217343 
4.50e+08 0.9601937 
4.67e+08 -0.757537 
4.83e+08 -3.06678 
5.00e+08 -5.635237 
5.17e+08 -8.2271 
5.33e+08 -9.618924 
5.50e+08 -9.791239 
5.67e+08 -9.201792 
5.83e+08 -9.086395 
6.00e+08 -9.560636 
6.17e+08 -10.94548 
6.33e+08 -13.11583 
6.50e+08 -16.3255 
6.67e+08 -22.45401 
6.83e+08 -34.91041 
7.00e+08 -18.52293 
7.17e+08 -12.31584 
7.33e+08 -8.076791 
7.50e+08 -5.287256 
7.67e+08 -3.399354 
7.83e+08 -2.394224 
8.00e+08 -2.031315 
8.17e+08 -2.07204 
8.33e+08 -2.531995 
8.50e+08 -3.185455 
8.67e+08 -4.223504 
8.83e+08 -5.275337 
9.00e+08 -6.274862 
9.17e+08 -6.532893 
9.33e+08 -6.242696 
9.50e+08 -5.514515 
9.67e+08 -4.831669 
9.83e+08 -4.240883 
1.00e+09 -3.779134 
1.02e+09 -3.558248 
1.03e+09 -3.38254 
1.05e+09 -3.543484 
1.07e+09 -3.611961 
Attachment 2: vv_el_1
8.33e+07 -19.61153 
1.00e+08 -21.05896 
1.17e+08 -21.14054 
1.33e+08 -20.63561 
1.50e+08 -20.56293 
1.67e+08 -21.11712 
1.83e+08 -21.6924 
2.00e+08 -22.23107 
2.17e+08 -22.38623 
2.33e+08 -22.01034 
2.50e+08 -20.95566 
2.67e+08 -19.49215 
2.83e+08 -19.23056 
3.00e+08 -21.02166 
3.17e+08 -24.84512 
3.33e+08 -30.42641 
3.50e+08 -30.39998 
3.67e+08 -24.79053 
3.83e+08 -20.92692 
4.00e+08 -18.28975 
4.17e+08 -16.42205 
4.33e+08 -15.10437 
4.50e+08 -14.27861 
4.67e+08 -13.84517 
4.83e+08 -13.72481 
5.00e+08 -13.71555 
5.17e+08 -13.67698 
5.33e+08 -13.47088 
5.50e+08 -13.12691 
5.67e+08 -12.80078 
5.83e+08 -12.76288 
6.00e+08 -13.29937 
6.17e+08 -14.53883 
6.33e+08 -16.51551 
6.50e+08 -19.31712 
6.67e+08 -23.38054 
6.83e+08 -28.77149 
7.00e+08 -26.26056 
7.17e+08 -20.68733 
7.33e+08 -16.92428 
7.50e+08 -14.40974 
7.67e+08 -12.83548 
7.83e+08 -11.95044 
8.00e+08 -11.46287 
8.17e+08 -11.11874 
8.33e+08 -10.75576 
8.50e+08 -10.35075 
8.67e+08 -9.963577 
8.83e+08 -9.712427 
9.00e+08 -9.691508 
9.17e+08 -9.958833 
9.33e+08 -10.48243 
9.50e+08 -11.25391 
9.67e+08 -12.16331 
9.83e+08 -13.22009 
1.00e+09 -14.23114 
1.02e+09 -15.10789 
1.03e+09 -15.45052 
1.05e+09 -15.20106 
1.07e+09 -14.44125 
8.33e+07 -13.61057 
1.00e+08 -15.05177 
1.17e+08 -15.12521 
1.33e+08 -14.60951 
1.50e+08 -14.52322 
1.67e+08 -15.06334 
1.83e+08 -15.62302 
2.00e+08 -16.1491 
2.17e+08 -16.29245 
2.33e+08 -15.91477 
2.50e+08 -14.8618 
2.67e+08 -13.39692 
2.83e+08 -13.1095 
3.00e+08 -14.84329 
3.17e+08 -18.54948 
3.33e+08 -24.02788 
3.50e+08 -24.85216 
3.67e+08 -19.17134 
3.83e+08 -15.1775 
4.00e+08 -12.46181 
4.17e+08 -10.53846 
4.33e+08 -9.176889 
4.50e+08 -8.313917 
4.67e+08 -7.849362 
4.83e+08 -7.705056 
5.00e+08 -7.681289 
5.17e+08 -7.638247 
5.33e+08 -7.434054 
5.50e+08 -7.090922 
5.67e+08 -6.756147 
5.83e+08 -6.694556 
6.00e+08 -7.188318 
6.17e+08 -8.361327 
6.33e+08 -10.23697 
6.50e+08 -12.87492 
6.67e+08 -16.64803 
6.83e+08 -21.92072 
7.00e+08 -21.02616 
7.17e+08 -15.29548 
7.33e+08 -11.32251 
7.50e+08 -8.680712 
7.67e+08 -7.026238 
7.83e+08 -6.092156 
8.00e+08 -5.577537 
8.17e+08 -5.222755 
8.33e+08 -4.855792 
8.50e+08 -4.445815 
8.67e+08 -4.04485 
8.83e+08 -3.769133 
9.00e+08 -3.712655 
9.17e+08 -3.934655 
9.33e+08 -4.405427 
9.50e+08 -5.116381 
9.67e+08 -5.962245 
9.83e+08 -6.955142 
1.00e+09 -7.921253 
1.02e+09 -8.79726 
1.03e+09 -9.21963 
1.05e+09 -9.101768 
1.07e+09 -8.46457 
8.33e+07 -7.672357 
1.00e+08 -9.089356 
1.17e+08 -9.131313 
1.33e+08 -8.574198 
1.50e+08 -8.436004 
1.67e+08 -8.923278 
1.83e+08 -9.424584 
2.00e+08 -9.903976 
2.17e+08 -10.00275 
2.33e+08 -9.618365 
2.50e+08 -8.573076 
2.67e+08 -7.108304 
2.83e+08 -6.730207 
3.00e+08 -8.258189 
3.17e+08 -11.54483 
3.33e+08 -16.48101 
3.50e+08 -20.44362 
3.67e+08 -14.99668 
3.83e+08 -10.39325 
4.00e+08 -7.322492 
4.17e+08 -5.15867 
4.33e+08 -3.614434 
4.50e+08 -2.600771 
4.67e+08 -2.012469 
4.83e+08 -1.773685 
5.00e+08 -1.692136 
5.17e+08 -1.631185 
5.33e+08 -1.436829 
5.50e+08 -1.104481 
5.67e+08 -0.7477778 
5.83e+08 -0.6082266 
6.00e+08 -0.9526983 
6.17e+08 -1.891183 
6.33e+08 -3.416407 
6.50e+08 -5.508213 
6.67e+08 -8.350483 
6.83e+08 -12.36274 
7.00e+08 -15.94441 
7.17e+08 -11.94184 
7.33e+08 -7.215725 
7.50e+08 -4.031596 
7.67e+08 -2.033106 
7.83e+08 -0.8896422 
8.00e+08 -0.2599349 
8.17e+08 0.1364451 
8.33e+08 0.508579 
8.50e+08 0.9189453 
8.67e+08 1.351561 
8.83e+08 1.703014 
9.00e+08 1.881713 
9.17e+08 1.823472 
9.33e+08 1.546895 
9.50e+08 1.061567 
9.67e+08 0.4561304 
9.83e+08 -0.2820854 
1.00e+09 -1.030102 
1.02e+09 -1.782719 
1.03e+09 -2.307445 
1.05e+09 -2.516682 
1.07e+09 -2.306051 
8.33e+07 -4.297208 
1.00e+08 -5.677257 
1.17e+08 -5.671377 
1.33e+08 -5.051709 
1.50e+08 -4.836023 
1.67e+08 -5.245572 
1.83e+08 -5.661229 
2.00e+08 -6.072461 
2.17e+08 -6.104968 
2.33e+08 -5.710936 
2.50e+08 -4.682109 
2.67e+08 -3.235083 
2.83e+08 -2.745363 
3.00e+08 -3.999428 
3.17e+08 -6.728222 
3.33e+08 -10.71871 
3.50e+08 -16.85379 
3.67e+08 -15.67102 
3.83e+08 -9.610837 
4.00e+08 -5.713407 
4.17e+08 -3.051436 
4.33e+08 -1.161082 
4.50e+08 0.1202912 
4.67e+08 0.9189369 
4.83e+08 1.315152 
5.00e+08 1.493735 
5.17e+08 1.58528 
5.33e+08 1.756137 
5.50e+08 2.045786 
5.67e+08 2.395989 
5.83e+08 2.609925 
6.00e+08 2.448707 
6.17e+08 1.814713 
6.33e+08 0.7368893 
6.50e+08 -0.702895 
6.67e+08 -2.543868 
6.83e+08 -4.926394 
7.00e+08 -7.929486 
7.17e+08 -9.722289 
7.33e+08 -6.876765 
7.50e+08 -3.230588 
7.67e+08 -0.6956752 
7.83e+08 0.8078526 
8.00e+08 1.641694 
8.17e+08 2.100993 
8.33e+08 2.439688 
8.50e+08 2.768471 
8.67e+08 3.145787 
8.83e+08 3.516955 
9.00e+08 3.809434 
9.17e+08 3.95456 
9.33e+08 3.942741 
9.50e+08 3.779913 
9.67e+08 3.52297 
9.83e+08 3.16981 
1.00e+09 2.79626 
1.02e+09 2.387999 
1.03e+09 2.060452 
1.05e+09 1.836171 
1.07e+09 1.800864 
8.33e+07 -1.144795 
1.00e+08 -2.455938 
1.17e+08 -2.361629 
1.33e+08 -1.627502 
1.50e+08 -1.273074 
1.67e+08 -1.547562 
1.83e+08 -1.814825 
2.00e+08 -2.110694 
2.17e+08 -2.028768 
2.33e+08 -1.626653 
2.50e+08 -0.6542816 
2.67e+08 0.689521 
2.83e+08 1.297091 
3.00e+08 0.4526482 
3.17e+08 -1.408842 
3.33e+08 -3.855139 
3.50e+08 -7.45269 
3.67e+08 -13.8242 
3.83e+08 -21.86369 
4.00e+08 -10.18875 
4.17e+08 -4.926253 
4.33e+08 -1.717269 
4.50e+08 0.408406 
4.67e+08 1.793992 
4.83e+08 2.602153 
5.00e+08 3.033494 
5.17e+08 3.210672 
5.33e+08 3.304456 
5.50e+08 3.387133 
5.67e+08 3.514676 
5.83e+08 3.634609 
6.00e+08 3.636984 
6.17e+08 3.453297 
6.33e+08 3.09098 
6.50e+08 2.620621 
6.67e+08 2.051623 
6.83e+08 1.398647 
7.00e+08 0.6288801 
7.17e+08 -0.2089145 
7.33e+08 -0.8729058 
7.50e+08 -0.8983268 
7.67e+08 -0.1494044 
7.83e+08 0.8073187 
8.00e+08 1.548733 
8.17e+08 1.943862 
8.33e+08 2.050232 
8.50e+08 1.890077 
8.67e+08 1.512847 
8.83e+08 0.9992631 
9.00e+08 0.4794029 
9.17e+08 0.180576 
9.33e+08 0.1580454 
9.50e+08 0.4193046 
9.67e+08 0.7895336 
9.83e+08 1.223261 
1.00e+09 1.625476 
1.02e+09 2.006417 
1.03e+09 2.338812 
1.05e+09 2.613677 
1.07e+09 2.839776 
... 61 more lines ...
  194   Mon Feb 13 14:56:57 2023 Jack TillmanBuilding - Physics Plots for 9_50, 13_84, 18_89, 19_96, 29_87 Antennae

Physics plots were created for 300K events from the higher statistic simulation results for the 9_50, 13_84, 18_89, 19_96, and 29_87 antennae. 

The simulation was inaccurate because a discrepancy exists between the higher simulation physics plots and the physics plots created for the 300K event results currently in the GENETIS Loop. This can be seen in the attached pdf file. 

The simulation may have been inaccurate due to incorrect gain files. 

The higher statistic simulations must be rerun for the 9_50, 13_84, 18_89, 19_96, and 29_87 antennae.

 

Attachment 1: Genetis_Physics_Plot_Comparison_Slides.pdf
  193   Fri Feb 10 15:55:53 2023 Jack TillmanBuilding - Matching Circuit PCB

I've completed laying out the PCB for the 14-rung matching circuit. Attached are png files of two PCB designs. One uses LPS5050 inductors while the other uses LPS6235 inductors. The dimensions shown are in millimeters. 

Attachment 1: LPS5050_Dimensioned_PCB.png
LPS5050_Dimensioned_PCB.png
Attachment 2: LPS6235_Dimensioned_PCB.png
LPS6235_Dimensioned_PCB.png
  192   Mon Feb 6 13:20:26 2023 Dylan WellsPhysical Paramaters for the best antenna

Asym Straight Sides (from the paper - Generation 23, Individual 8)

(inner radius, length, opening angle in radians)

2.08711,89.924,0.0161734
0.30175,45.3616,0.0910478

individual found in 

/fs/project/PAS0654/BiconeEvolutionOSC/BiconeEvolution/current_antenna_evo_build/XF_Loop/Evolutionary_Loop/Run_Outputs/AraSim_Polarity_Fix_2021_03_19/AraSim_Polarity_Fix_2021_03_19.xf/Simulations/001108/Run0001/

 

  191   Mon Feb 6 10:23:53 2023 Dylan WellsMatching Circuit Parts

Attached is a spreadsheet with the information on the parts we need for the N=14 matching circuit board.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1x8dX3tNE-WSHjH_slj_EH4XsHcAnCVC05XiRBFPtIUc/edit#gid=0

  190   Tue Jan 31 15:31:29 2023 Alex MARA Bicone Responses

Here we will record where we obtained the ARA bicone antenna response files we use as our baselines. We want to record where we found them/who gave them to us and how they were generated (either through simulation or from actual tests).

  189   Tue Jan 31 11:30:54 2023 Audrey ZinnBuilding

Attached are the XF files for the top 5 individuals from the 2022_12_29 crazy sides run. In order from best to 5th best: 

1: Gen 29 Indiv 87

2: Gen 19 Indiv 96

3: Gen 13 Indiv 84

4: Gen 9 Indiv 50

5: Gen 18 Indiv 89

These can also be found in /fs/ess/PAS1960/BiconeEvolutionOSC/BiconeEvolution/current_antenna_evo_build/XF_Loop/Evolutionary_Loop/Run_Outputs/2022_12_29/2022_12_29.xf in the corresponding directories. 

Attachment 1: XF_model_13_84.txt
freq : 83.33 MHz
SWR : 1.965000
 Theta     Phi     Gain(dB)     Gain     Phase(deg) 
0 	 0 	 -64.90     	   0.00     	    -105.60
5 	 0 	 -19.63     	   0.01     	    -105.58
10 	 0 	 -13.64     	   0.04     	    -105.51
15 	 0 	 -10.17     	   0.10     	    -105.38
20 	 0 	 -7.75     	   0.17     	    -105.21
25 	 0 	 -5.90     	   0.26     	    -104.96
30 	 0 	 -4.43     	   0.36     	    -104.65
35 	 0 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    -104.25
40 	 0 	 -2.22     	   0.60     	    -103.75
45 	 0 	 -1.38     	   0.73     	    -103.11
50 	 0 	 -0.67     	   0.86     	    -102.31
55 	 0 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    -101.26
60 	 0 	 0.42     	   1.10     	    -99.87
65 	 0 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    -97.94
70 	 0 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    -95.09
75 	 0 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    -90.53
80 	 0 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    -82.17
85 	 0 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    -63.52
90 	 0 	 1.70     	   1.48     	    -19.53
95 	 0 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    24.56
100 	 0 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    43.26
105 	 0 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    51.64
110 	 0 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    56.22
115 	 0 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    59.07
120 	 0 	 0.41     	   1.10     	    61.01
125 	 0 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    62.41
130 	 0 	 -0.68     	   0.86     	    63.46
135 	 0 	 -1.39     	   0.73     	    64.28
140 	 0 	 -2.23     	   0.60     	    64.92
145 	 0 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    65.43
150 	 0 	 -4.44     	   0.36     	    65.84
155 	 0 	 -5.91     	   0.26     	    66.17
160 	 0 	 -7.76     	   0.17     	    66.42
165 	 0 	 -10.19     	   0.10     	    66.62
170 	 0 	 -13.66     	   0.04     	    66.75
175 	 0 	 -19.66     	   0.01     	    66.84
180 	 0 	 -64.87     	   0.00     	    66.87
0 	 5 	 -64.33     	   0.00     	    -107.33
5 	 5 	 -19.63     	   0.01     	    -107.32
10 	 5 	 -13.64     	   0.04     	    -107.27
15 	 5 	 -10.17     	   0.10     	    -107.18
20 	 5 	 -7.75     	   0.17     	    -107.05
25 	 5 	 -5.90     	   0.26     	    -106.88
30 	 5 	 -4.43     	   0.36     	    -106.65
35 	 5 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    -106.37
40 	 5 	 -2.22     	   0.60     	    -106.01
45 	 5 	 -1.38     	   0.73     	    -105.57
50 	 5 	 -0.67     	   0.86     	    -105.00
55 	 5 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    -104.28
60 	 5 	 0.42     	   1.10     	    -103.31
65 	 5 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    -101.97
70 	 5 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    -99.99
75 	 5 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    -96.77
80 	 5 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    -90.60
85 	 5 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    -74.77
90 	 5 	 1.70     	   1.48     	    -18.14
95 	 5 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    36.69
100 	 5 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    51.96
105 	 5 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    57.99
110 	 5 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    61.17
115 	 5 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    63.13
120 	 5 	 0.41     	   1.10     	    64.46
125 	 5 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    65.43
130 	 5 	 -0.68     	   0.86     	    66.16
135 	 5 	 -1.39     	   0.73     	    66.73
140 	 5 	 -2.23     	   0.60     	    67.19
145 	 5 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    67.56
150 	 5 	 -4.44     	   0.36     	    67.85
155 	 5 	 -5.91     	   0.26     	    68.09
160 	 5 	 -7.76     	   0.17     	    68.27
165 	 5 	 -10.19     	   0.10     	    68.42
170 	 5 	 -13.66     	   0.04     	    68.52
175 	 5 	 -19.66     	   0.01     	    68.58
180 	 5 	 -64.30     	   0.00     	    68.61
0 	 10 	 -63.85     	   0.00     	    -109.51
5 	 10 	 -19.63     	   0.01     	    -109.51
10 	 10 	 -13.64     	   0.04     	    -109.49
15 	 10 	 -10.17     	   0.10     	    -109.45
20 	 10 	 -7.75     	   0.17     	    -109.38
25 	 10 	 -5.90     	   0.26     	    -109.30
30 	 10 	 -4.43     	   0.36     	    -109.19
35 	 10 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    -109.06
40 	 10 	 -2.22     	   0.60     	    -108.89
45 	 10 	 -1.38     	   0.73     	    -108.69
50 	 10 	 -0.67     	   0.86     	    -108.44
55 	 10 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    -108.13
60 	 10 	 0.42     	   1.10     	    -107.73
65 	 10 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    -107.19
70 	 10 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    -106.41
75 	 10 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    -105.17
80 	 10 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    -102.75
85 	 10 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    -95.68
90 	 10 	 1.70     	   1.48     	    -10.72
95 	 10 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    57.68
100 	 10 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    64.05
105 	 10 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    66.34
110 	 10 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    67.55
115 	 10 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    68.31
120 	 10 	 0.41     	   1.10     	    68.85
125 	 10 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    69.26
130 	 10 	 -0.68     	   0.86     	    69.58
135 	 10 	 -1.39     	   0.73     	    69.84
140 	 10 	 -2.23     	   0.60     	    70.06
145 	 10 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    70.24
150 	 10 	 -4.44     	   0.36     	    70.39
155 	 10 	 -5.91     	   0.26     	    70.51
160 	 10 	 -7.76     	   0.17     	    70.61
165 	 10 	 -10.19     	   0.10     	    70.69
170 	 10 	 -13.66     	   0.04     	    70.75
175 	 10 	 -19.66     	   0.01     	    70.78
180 	 10 	 -63.82     	   0.00     	    70.80
0 	 15 	 -63.45     	   0.00     	    -112.40
5 	 15 	 -19.63     	   0.01     	    -112.41
10 	 15 	 -13.64     	   0.04     	    -112.42
15 	 15 	 -10.17     	   0.10     	    -112.44
20 	 15 	 -7.75     	   0.17     	    -112.47
25 	 15 	 -5.90     	   0.26     	    -112.50
30 	 15 	 -4.43     	   0.36     	    -112.55
35 	 15 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    -112.61
40 	 15 	 -2.22     	   0.60     	    -112.70
45 	 15 	 -1.38     	   0.73     	    -112.83
50 	 15 	 -0.67     	   0.86     	    -113.01
55 	 15 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    -113.26
60 	 15 	 0.42     	   1.10     	    -113.63
65 	 15 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    -114.19
70 	 15 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    -115.09
75 	 15 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    -116.67
80 	 15 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    -119.98
85 	 15 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    -130.06
90 	 15 	 1.70     	   1.48     	    150.28
95 	 15 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    88.84
100 	 15 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    80.40
105 	 15 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    77.44
110 	 15 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    75.99
115 	 15 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    75.16
120 	 15 	 0.41     	   1.10     	    74.65
125 	 15 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    74.32
130 	 15 	 -0.68     	   0.86     	    74.09
135 	 15 	 -1.39     	   0.73     	    73.95
140 	 15 	 -2.23     	   0.60     	    73.85
145 	 15 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    73.78
150 	 15 	 -4.44     	   0.36     	    73.74
155 	 15 	 -5.91     	   0.26     	    73.71
160 	 15 	 -7.76     	   0.17     	    73.70
165 	 15 	 -10.19     	   0.10     	    73.69
170 	 15 	 -13.66     	   0.04     	    73.69
175 	 15 	 -19.66     	   0.01     	    73.70
180 	 15 	 -63.42     	   0.00     	    73.71
0 	 20 	 -63.14     	   0.00     	    -116.43
5 	 20 	 -19.63     	   0.01     	    -116.46
10 	 20 	 -13.64     	   0.04     	    -116.53
15 	 20 	 -10.17     	   0.10     	    -116.63
20 	 20 	 -7.75     	   0.17     	    -116.78
25 	 20 	 -5.90     	   0.26     	    -116.98
30 	 20 	 -4.43     	   0.36     	    -117.25
35 	 20 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    -117.59
40 	 20 	 -2.22     	   0.60     	    -118.04
45 	 20 	 -1.38     	   0.73     	    -118.62
50 	 20 	 -0.67     	   0.86     	    -119.39
55 	 20 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    -120.42
60 	 20 	 0.42     	   1.10     	    -121.84
65 	 20 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    -123.88
70 	 20 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    -126.97
75 	 20 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    -132.07
80 	 20 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    -141.54
85 	 20 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    -162.14
90 	 20 	 1.70     	   1.48     	    155.74
95 	 20 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    117.62
100 	 20 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    100.14
105 	 20 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    91.86
110 	 20 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    87.29
115 	 20 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    84.47
120 	 20 	 0.41     	   1.10     	    82.60
125 	 20 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    81.29
130 	 20 	 -0.68     	   0.86     	    80.35
135 	 20 	 -1.39     	   0.73     	    79.64
140 	 20 	 -2.23     	   0.60     	    79.12
145 	 20 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    78.72
150 	 20 	 -4.44     	   0.36     	    78.41
155 	 20 	 -5.91     	   0.26     	    78.18
160 	 20 	 -7.76     	   0.17     	    78.02
165 	 20 	 -10.19     	   0.10     	    77.90
170 	 20 	 -13.66     	   0.04     	    77.82
175 	 20 	 -19.66     	   0.01     	    77.78
180 	 20 	 -63.11     	   0.00     	    77.78
0 	 25 	 -62.89     	   0.00     	    -122.51
5 	 25 	 -19.63     	   0.01     	    -122.57
10 	 25 	 -13.64     	   0.04     	    -122.71
15 	 25 	 -10.17     	   0.10     	    -122.95
20 	 25 	 -7.75     	   0.17     	    -123.28
25 	 25 	 -5.90     	   0.26     	    -123.72
30 	 25 	 -4.43     	   0.36     	    -124.31
35 	 25 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    -125.05
40 	 25 	 -2.22     	   0.60     	    -126.00
45 	 25 	 -1.38     	   0.73     	    -127.22
50 	 25 	 -0.67     	   0.86     	    -128.80
55 	 25 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    -130.86
60 	 25 	 0.42     	   1.10     	    -133.62
65 	 25 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    -137.41
70 	 25 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    -142.79
75 	 25 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    -150.72
80 	 25 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    -162.72
85 	 25 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    179.55
90 	 25 	 1.70     	   1.48     	    157.02
95 	 25 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    135.52
100 	 25 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    119.63
105 	 25 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    109.06
110 	 25 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    102.05
115 	 25 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    97.25
120 	 25 	 0.41     	   1.10     	    93.83
125 	 25 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    91.34
130 	 25 	 -0.68     	   0.86     	    89.46
135 	 25 	 -1.39     	   0.73     	    88.03
140 	 25 	 -2.23     	   0.60     	    86.93
145 	 25 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    86.07
150 	 25 	 -4.44     	   0.36     	    85.40
155 	 25 	 -5.91     	   0.26     	    84.89
160 	 25 	 -7.76     	   0.17     	    84.50
165 	 25 	 -10.19     	   0.10     	    84.22
170 	 25 	 -13.66     	   0.04     	    84.04
175 	 25 	 -19.66     	   0.01     	    83.94
180 	 25 	 -62.87     	   0.00     	    83.92
0 	 30 	 -62.72     	   0.00     	    -132.56
5 	 30 	 -19.63     	   0.01     	    -132.68
10 	 30 	 -13.64     	   0.04     	    -132.94
15 	 30 	 -10.17     	   0.10     	    -133.37
20 	 30 	 -7.75     	   0.17     	    -133.97
25 	 30 	 -5.90     	   0.26     	    -134.77
30 	 30 	 -4.43     	   0.36     	    -135.79
35 	 30 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    -137.09
40 	 30 	 -2.22     	   0.60     	    -138.71
45 	 30 	 -1.38     	   0.73     	    -140.72
50 	 30 	 -0.67     	   0.86     	    -143.24
55 	 30 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    -146.39
60 	 30 	 0.42     	   1.10     	    -150.34
65 	 30 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    -155.35
70 	 30 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    -161.66
75 	 30 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    -169.57
80 	 30 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    -179.20
85 	 30 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    169.63
90 	 30 	 1.70     	   1.48     	    157.66
95 	 30 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    145.96
100 	 30 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    135.50
105 	 30 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    126.73
110 	 30 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    119.66
115 	 30 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    114.04
120 	 30 	 0.41     	   1.10     	    109.61
125 	 30 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    106.09
130 	 30 	 -0.68     	   0.86     	    103.30
135 	 30 	 -1.39     	   0.73     	    101.07
140 	 30 	 -2.23     	   0.60     	    99.29
145 	 30 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    97.86
150 	 30 	 -4.44     	   0.36     	    96.72
155 	 30 	 -5.91     	   0.26     	    95.83
160 	 30 	 -7.76     	   0.17     	    95.15
165 	 30 	 -10.19     	   0.10     	    94.66
170 	 30 	 -13.66     	   0.04     	    94.33
175 	 30 	 -19.66     	   0.01     	    94.15
180 	 30 	 -62.70     	   0.00     	    94.13
0 	 35 	 -62.62     	   0.00     	    -150.86
5 	 35 	 -19.63     	   0.01     	    -151.07
10 	 35 	 -13.64     	   0.04     	    -151.49
15 	 35 	 -10.17     	   0.10     	    -152.14
20 	 35 	 -7.75     	   0.17     	    -153.03
25 	 35 	 -5.90     	   0.26     	    -154.18
30 	 35 	 -4.43     	   0.36     	    -155.60
35 	 35 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    -157.32
40 	 35 	 -2.22     	   0.60     	    -159.38
45 	 35 	 -1.38     	   0.73     	    -161.80
50 	 35 	 -0.67     	   0.86     	    -164.62
55 	 35 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    -167.87
60 	 35 	 0.42     	   1.10     	    -171.57
65 	 35 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    -175.73
70 	 35 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    179.66
75 	 35 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    174.64
80 	 35 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    169.28
85 	 35 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    163.72
90 	 35 	 1.70     	   1.48     	    158.08
95 	 35 	 1.67     	   1.47     	    152.52
100 	 35 	 1.56     	   1.43     	    147.18
105 	 35 	 1.39     	   1.38     	    142.18
110 	 35 	 1.14     	   1.30     	    137.59
115 	 35 	 0.82     	   1.21     	    133.45
120 	 35 	 0.41     	   1.10     	    129.78
125 	 35 	 -0.08     	   0.98     	    126.55
130 	 35 	 -0.68     	   0.86     	    123.75
135 	 35 	 -1.39     	   0.73     	    121.34
140 	 35 	 -2.23     	   0.60     	    119.29
145 	 35 	 -3.23     	   0.48     	    117.57
150 	 35 	 -4.44     	   0.36     	    116.14
155 	 35 	 -5.91     	   0.26     	    114.99
160 	 35 	 -7.76     	   0.17     	    114.09
165 	 35 	 -10.19     	   0.10     	    113.43
170 	 35 	 -13.66     	   0.04     	    113.00
175 	 35 	 -19.66     	   0.01     	    112.78
180 	 35 	 -62.60     	   0.00     	    112.77
0 	 40 	 -62.58     	   0.00     	    177.48
... 159721 more lines ...
Attachment 2: XF_model_9_50.txt
freq : 83.33 MHz
SWR : 1.965000
 Theta     Phi     Gain(dB)     Gain     Phase(deg) 
0 	 0 	 -65.66     	   0.00     	    68.97
5 	 0 	 -23.00     	   0.01     	    68.99
10 	 0 	 -17.02     	   0.02     	    69.05
15 	 0 	 -13.55     	   0.04     	    69.15
20 	 0 	 -11.13     	   0.08     	    69.30
25 	 0 	 -9.29     	   0.12     	    69.49
30 	 0 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    69.75
35 	 0 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    70.06
40 	 0 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    70.43
45 	 0 	 -4.79     	   0.33     	    70.90
50 	 0 	 -4.09     	   0.39     	    71.47
55 	 0 	 -3.50     	   0.45     	    72.18
60 	 0 	 -3.01     	   0.50     	    73.09
65 	 0 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    74.31
70 	 0 	 -2.29     	   0.59     	    76.06
75 	 0 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    78.83
80 	 0 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    84.06
85 	 0 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    97.84
90 	 0 	 -1.74     	   0.67     	    159.48
95 	 0 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    -139.66
100 	 0 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    -126.04
105 	 0 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    -120.85
110 	 0 	 -2.30     	   0.59     	    -118.08
115 	 0 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    -116.34
120 	 0 	 -3.02     	   0.50     	    -115.12
125 	 0 	 -3.51     	   0.45     	    -114.20
130 	 0 	 -4.10     	   0.39     	    -113.48
135 	 0 	 -4.80     	   0.33     	    -112.91
140 	 0 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    -112.44
145 	 0 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    -112.05
150 	 0 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -111.73
155 	 0 	 -9.30     	   0.12     	    -111.47
160 	 0 	 -11.14     	   0.08     	    -111.26
165 	 0 	 -13.57     	   0.04     	    -111.10
170 	 0 	 -17.04     	   0.02     	    -110.98
175 	 0 	 -23.04     	   0.00     	    -110.91
180 	 0 	 -65.62     	   0.00     	    -110.88
0 	 5 	 -66.34     	   0.00     	    70.70
5 	 5 	 -23.00     	   0.01     	    70.72
10 	 5 	 -17.02     	   0.02     	    70.80
15 	 5 	 -13.55     	   0.04     	    70.93
20 	 5 	 -11.13     	   0.08     	    71.12
25 	 5 	 -9.29     	   0.12     	    71.39
30 	 5 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    71.72
35 	 5 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    72.14
40 	 5 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    72.65
45 	 5 	 -4.79     	   0.33     	    73.29
50 	 5 	 -4.09     	   0.39     	    74.09
55 	 5 	 -3.50     	   0.45     	    75.11
60 	 5 	 -3.01     	   0.50     	    76.44
65 	 5 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    78.24
70 	 5 	 -2.29     	   0.59     	    80.87
75 	 5 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    85.05
80 	 5 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    92.78
85 	 5 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    110.94
90 	 5 	 -1.74     	   0.67     	    160.03
95 	 5 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    -152.08
100 	 5 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    -134.51
105 	 5 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    -126.96
110 	 5 	 -2.30     	   0.59     	    -122.85
115 	 5 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    -120.26
120 	 5 	 -3.02     	   0.50     	    -118.46
125 	 5 	 -3.51     	   0.45     	    -117.14
130 	 5 	 -4.10     	   0.39     	    -116.13
135 	 5 	 -4.80     	   0.33     	    -115.32
140 	 5 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    -114.67
145 	 5 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    -114.15
150 	 5 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -113.72
155 	 5 	 -9.30     	   0.12     	    -113.38
160 	 5 	 -11.14     	   0.08     	    -113.10
165 	 5 	 -13.57     	   0.04     	    -112.89
170 	 5 	 -17.04     	   0.02     	    -112.75
175 	 5 	 -23.04     	   0.00     	    -112.66
180 	 5 	 -66.29     	   0.00     	    -112.62
0 	 10 	 -67.14     	   0.00     	    72.17
5 	 10 	 -23.00     	   0.01     	    72.19
10 	 10 	 -17.02     	   0.02     	    72.28
15 	 10 	 -13.55     	   0.04     	    72.45
20 	 10 	 -11.13     	   0.08     	    72.68
25 	 10 	 -9.29     	   0.12     	    72.99
30 	 10 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    73.40
35 	 10 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    73.91
40 	 10 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    74.54
45 	 10 	 -4.79     	   0.33     	    75.33
50 	 10 	 -4.09     	   0.39     	    76.32
55 	 10 	 -3.50     	   0.45     	    77.59
60 	 10 	 -3.01     	   0.50     	    79.26
65 	 10 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    81.54
70 	 10 	 -2.29     	   0.59     	    84.86
75 	 10 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    90.10
80 	 10 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    99.46
85 	 10 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    119.21
90 	 10 	 -1.74     	   0.67     	    160.25
95 	 10 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    -159.82
100 	 10 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    -140.91
105 	 10 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    -131.87
110 	 10 	 -2.30     	   0.59     	    -126.77
115 	 10 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    -123.52
120 	 10 	 -3.02     	   0.50     	    -121.27
125 	 10 	 -3.51     	   0.45     	    -119.61
130 	 10 	 -4.10     	   0.39     	    -118.35
135 	 10 	 -4.80     	   0.33     	    -117.36
140 	 10 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    -116.57
145 	 10 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    -115.93
150 	 10 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -115.41
155 	 10 	 -9.30     	   0.12     	    -114.99
160 	 10 	 -11.14     	   0.08     	    -114.67
165 	 10 	 -13.57     	   0.04     	    -114.42
170 	 10 	 -17.04     	   0.02     	    -114.25
175 	 10 	 -23.04     	   0.00     	    -114.14
180 	 10 	 -67.09     	   0.00     	    -114.10
0 	 15 	 -68.08     	   0.00     	    73.45
5 	 15 	 -23.00     	   0.01     	    73.48
10 	 15 	 -17.02     	   0.02     	    73.58
15 	 15 	 -13.55     	   0.04     	    73.77
20 	 15 	 -11.13     	   0.08     	    74.04
25 	 15 	 -9.29     	   0.12     	    74.40
30 	 15 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    74.86
35 	 15 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    75.45
40 	 15 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    76.18
45 	 15 	 -4.79     	   0.33     	    77.10
50 	 15 	 -4.09     	   0.39     	    78.26
55 	 15 	 -3.50     	   0.45     	    79.74
60 	 15 	 -3.01     	   0.50     	    81.70
65 	 15 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    84.37
70 	 15 	 -2.29     	   0.59     	    88.24
75 	 15 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    94.27
80 	 15 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    104.69
85 	 15 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    124.77
90 	 15 	 -1.74     	   0.67     	    160.35
95 	 15 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    -165.00
100 	 15 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    -145.87
105 	 15 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    -135.89
110 	 15 	 -2.30     	   0.59     	    -130.06
115 	 15 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    -126.29
120 	 15 	 -3.02     	   0.50     	    -123.67
125 	 15 	 -3.51     	   0.45     	    -121.74
130 	 15 	 -4.10     	   0.39     	    -120.28
135 	 15 	 -4.80     	   0.33     	    -119.13
140 	 15 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    -118.21
145 	 15 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    -117.47
150 	 15 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -116.88
155 	 15 	 -9.30     	   0.12     	    -116.40
160 	 15 	 -11.14     	   0.08     	    -116.03
165 	 15 	 -13.57     	   0.04     	    -115.75
170 	 15 	 -17.04     	   0.02     	    -115.55
175 	 15 	 -23.04     	   0.00     	    -115.43
180 	 15 	 -68.02     	   0.00     	    -115.39
0 	 20 	 -69.19     	   0.00     	    74.59
5 	 20 	 -23.00     	   0.01     	    74.62
10 	 20 	 -17.02     	   0.02     	    74.74
15 	 20 	 -13.55     	   0.04     	    74.95
20 	 20 	 -11.13     	   0.08     	    75.25
25 	 20 	 -9.29     	   0.12     	    75.65
30 	 20 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    76.17
35 	 20 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    76.82
40 	 20 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    77.64
45 	 20 	 -4.79     	   0.33     	    78.67
50 	 20 	 -4.09     	   0.39     	    79.97
55 	 20 	 -3.50     	   0.45     	    81.64
60 	 20 	 -3.01     	   0.50     	    83.84
65 	 20 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    86.85
70 	 20 	 -2.29     	   0.59     	    91.16
75 	 20 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    97.79
80 	 20 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    108.88
85 	 20 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    128.73
90 	 20 	 -1.74     	   0.67     	    160.41
95 	 20 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    -168.71
100 	 20 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    -149.83
105 	 20 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    -139.26
110 	 20 	 -2.30     	   0.59     	    -132.89
115 	 20 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    -128.71
120 	 20 	 -3.02     	   0.50     	    -125.78
125 	 20 	 -3.51     	   0.45     	    -123.62
130 	 20 	 -4.10     	   0.39     	    -121.98
135 	 20 	 -4.80     	   0.33     	    -120.69
140 	 20 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    -119.66
145 	 20 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    -118.84
150 	 20 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -118.18
155 	 20 	 -9.30     	   0.12     	    -117.66
160 	 20 	 -11.14     	   0.08     	    -117.24
165 	 20 	 -13.57     	   0.04     	    -116.93
170 	 20 	 -17.04     	   0.02     	    -116.72
175 	 20 	 -23.04     	   0.00     	    -116.58
180 	 20 	 -69.13     	   0.00     	    -116.53
0 	 25 	 -70.51     	   0.00     	    75.63
5 	 25 	 -23.00     	   0.01     	    75.67
10 	 25 	 -17.02     	   0.02     	    75.80
15 	 25 	 -13.56     	   0.04     	    76.02
20 	 25 	 -11.13     	   0.08     	    76.35
25 	 25 	 -9.29     	   0.12     	    76.79
30 	 25 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    77.35
35 	 25 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    78.07
40 	 25 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    78.97
45 	 25 	 -4.79     	   0.33     	    80.10
50 	 25 	 -4.09     	   0.39     	    81.52
55 	 25 	 -3.50     	   0.45     	    83.36
60 	 25 	 -3.01     	   0.50     	    85.77
65 	 25 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    89.05
70 	 25 	 -2.29     	   0.59     	    93.74
75 	 25 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    100.82
80 	 25 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    112.32
85 	 25 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    131.71
90 	 25 	 -1.74     	   0.67     	    160.43
95 	 25 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    -171.53
100 	 25 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    -153.09
105 	 25 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    -142.16
110 	 25 	 -2.30     	   0.59     	    -135.37
115 	 25 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    -130.85
120 	 25 	 -3.02     	   0.50     	    -127.66
125 	 25 	 -3.51     	   0.45     	    -125.31
130 	 25 	 -4.10     	   0.39     	    -123.51
135 	 25 	 -4.80     	   0.33     	    -122.10
140 	 25 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    -120.98
145 	 25 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    -120.09
150 	 25 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -119.37
155 	 25 	 -9.30     	   0.12     	    -118.79
160 	 25 	 -11.14     	   0.08     	    -118.35
165 	 25 	 -13.57     	   0.04     	    -118.01
170 	 25 	 -17.04     	   0.02     	    -117.77
175 	 25 	 -23.04     	   0.00     	    -117.63
180 	 25 	 -70.44     	   0.00     	    -117.58
0 	 30 	 -72.08     	   0.00     	    76.59
5 	 30 	 -23.00     	   0.01     	    76.63
10 	 30 	 -17.02     	   0.02     	    76.77
15 	 30 	 -13.56     	   0.04     	    77.02
20 	 30 	 -11.13     	   0.08     	    77.37
25 	 30 	 -9.29     	   0.12     	    77.84
30 	 30 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    78.45
35 	 30 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    79.23
40 	 30 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    80.20
45 	 30 	 -4.79     	   0.33     	    81.41
50 	 30 	 -4.09     	   0.39     	    82.96
55 	 30 	 -3.50     	   0.45     	    84.93
60 	 30 	 -3.01     	   0.50     	    87.53
65 	 30 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    91.06
70 	 30 	 -2.29     	   0.59     	    96.04
75 	 30 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    103.48
80 	 30 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    115.21
85 	 30 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    134.04
90 	 30 	 -1.74     	   0.67     	    160.43
95 	 30 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    -173.76
100 	 30 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    -155.84
105 	 30 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    -144.70
110 	 30 	 -2.30     	   0.59     	    -137.59
115 	 30 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    -132.79
120 	 30 	 -3.02     	   0.50     	    -129.38
125 	 30 	 -3.51     	   0.45     	    -126.85
130 	 30 	 -4.10     	   0.39     	    -124.91
135 	 30 	 -4.80     	   0.33     	    -123.40
140 	 30 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    -122.20
145 	 30 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    -121.23
150 	 30 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -120.46
155 	 30 	 -9.30     	   0.12     	    -119.84
160 	 30 	 -11.14     	   0.08     	    -119.36
165 	 30 	 -13.57     	   0.04     	    -119.00
170 	 30 	 -17.04     	   0.02     	    -118.75
175 	 30 	 -23.04     	   0.00     	    -118.60
180 	 30 	 -72.01     	   0.00     	    -118.54
0 	 35 	 -73.95     	   0.00     	    77.50
5 	 35 	 -23.00     	   0.01     	    77.55
10 	 35 	 -17.02     	   0.02     	    77.70
15 	 35 	 -13.56     	   0.04     	    77.95
20 	 35 	 -11.13     	   0.08     	    78.33
25 	 35 	 -9.29     	   0.12     	    78.83
30 	 35 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    79.49
35 	 35 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    80.31
40 	 35 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    81.35
45 	 35 	 -4.79     	   0.33     	    82.65
50 	 35 	 -4.09     	   0.39     	    84.29
55 	 35 	 -3.50     	   0.45     	    86.40
60 	 35 	 -3.01     	   0.50     	    89.17
65 	 35 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    92.90
70 	 35 	 -2.29     	   0.59     	    98.15
75 	 35 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    105.86
80 	 35 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    117.70
85 	 35 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    135.93
90 	 35 	 -1.74     	   0.67     	    160.42
95 	 35 	 -1.78     	   0.66     	    -175.60
100 	 35 	 -1.88     	   0.65     	    -158.22
105 	 35 	 -2.05     	   0.62     	    -146.97
110 	 35 	 -2.30     	   0.59     	    -139.62
115 	 35 	 -2.61     	   0.55     	    -134.58
120 	 35 	 -3.02     	   0.50     	    -130.97
125 	 35 	 -3.51     	   0.45     	    -128.29
130 	 35 	 -4.10     	   0.39     	    -126.23
135 	 35 	 -4.80     	   0.33     	    -124.62
140 	 35 	 -5.63     	   0.27     	    -123.33
145 	 35 	 -6.63     	   0.22     	    -122.31
150 	 35 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -121.49
155 	 35 	 -9.30     	   0.12     	    -120.83
160 	 35 	 -11.14     	   0.08     	    -120.32
165 	 35 	 -13.57     	   0.04     	    -119.94
170 	 35 	 -17.04     	   0.02     	    -119.67
175 	 35 	 -23.04     	   0.00     	    -119.51
180 	 35 	 -73.87     	   0.00     	    -119.46
0 	 40 	 -76.10     	   0.00     	    78.37
... 159721 more lines ...
Attachment 3: XF_model_18_89.txt
freq : 83.33 MHz
SWR : 1.965000
 Theta     Phi     Gain(dB)     Gain     Phase(deg) 
0 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -25.63
5 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -25.69
10 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -25.72
15 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -25.73
20 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -25.71
25 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -25.66
30 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -25.58
35 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -25.48
40 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -25.35
45 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -25.20
50 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -25.02
55 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -24.82
60 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -24.59
65 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -24.33
70 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -24.06
75 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -23.76
80 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -23.44
85 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -23.11
90 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -22.76
95 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -22.39
100 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -22.02
105 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -21.63
110 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -21.24
115 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -20.85
120 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -20.46
125 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -20.07
130 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -19.70
135 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -19.34
140 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -18.99
145 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -18.67
150 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -18.37
155 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -18.09
160 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -17.85
165 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -17.64
170 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -17.47
175 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -17.33
180 	 0 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -17.23
0 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -57.01
5 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -56.84
10 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -56.42
15 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -55.73
20 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -54.77
25 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -53.53
30 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -52.01
35 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -50.20
40 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -48.07
45 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -45.62
50 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -42.84
55 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -39.72
60 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -36.29
65 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -32.55
70 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -28.55
75 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -24.35
80 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -20.01
85 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -15.63
90 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -11.28
95 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -7.06
100 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -3.05
105 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    0.71
110 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    4.17
115 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    7.31
120 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    10.11
125 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    12.60
130 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    14.77
135 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    16.65
140 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    18.25
145 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    19.59
150 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    20.70
155 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    21.58
160 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    22.25
165 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    22.74
170 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    23.03
175 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    23.15
180 	 5 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    23.10
0 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -64.53
5 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -64.32
10 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -63.83
15 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -63.05
20 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -61.97
25 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -60.57
30 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -58.84
35 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -56.75
40 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -54.27
45 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -51.37
50 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -48.02
55 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -44.20
60 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -39.91
65 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -35.16
70 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -30.01
75 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -24.54
80 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -18.89
85 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -13.22
90 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -7.66
95 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -2.37
100 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    2.54
105 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    7.02
110 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    11.02
115 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    14.56
120 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    17.64
125 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    20.29
130 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    22.57
135 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    24.49
140 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    26.11
145 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    27.44
150 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    28.52
155 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    29.37
160 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    30.01
165 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    30.45
170 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    30.71
175 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    30.79
180 	 10 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    30.71
0 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -67.78
5 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -67.56
10 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -67.05
15 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -66.24
20 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -65.13
25 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -63.69
30 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -61.90
35 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -59.72
40 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -57.12
45 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -54.05
50 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -50.47
55 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -46.35
60 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -41.67
65 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -36.45
70 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -30.73
75 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -24.64
80 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -18.34
85 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -12.03
90 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -5.90
95 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -0.13
100 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    5.17
105 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    9.92
110 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    14.11
115 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    17.75
120 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    20.89
125 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    23.58
130 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    25.85
135 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    27.76
140 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    29.35
145 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    30.65
150 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    31.70
155 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    32.52
160 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    33.14
165 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    33.56
170 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    33.80
175 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    33.87
180 	 15 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    33.78
0 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -69.61
5 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -69.38
10 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -68.87
15 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -68.05
20 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -66.92
25 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -65.47
30 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -63.65
35 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -61.43
40 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -58.77
45 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -55.61
50 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -51.92
55 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -47.63
60 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -42.73
65 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -37.23
70 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -31.18
75 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -24.71
80 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -18.02
85 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -11.32
90 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -4.86
95 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    1.18
100 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    6.68
105 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    11.57
110 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    15.84
115 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    19.54
120 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    22.70
125 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    25.38
130 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    27.64
135 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    29.54
140 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    31.11
145 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    32.39
150 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    33.42
155 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    34.23
160 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    34.83
165 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    35.24
170 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    35.47
175 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    35.54
180 	 20 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    35.45
0 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -70.79
5 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -70.56
10 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -70.04
15 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -69.23
20 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -68.10
25 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -66.63
30 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -64.80
35 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -62.56
40 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -59.86
45 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -56.66
50 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -52.88
55 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -48.49
60 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -43.45
65 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -37.76
70 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -31.49
75 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -24.77
80 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -17.81
85 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -10.86
90 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -4.18
95 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    2.03
100 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    7.65
105 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    12.62
110 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    16.95
115 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    20.67
120 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    23.83
125 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    26.51
130 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    28.77
135 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    30.65
140 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    32.21
145 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    33.48
150 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    34.50
155 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    35.30
160 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    35.89
165 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    36.30
170 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    36.53
175 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    36.60
180 	 25 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    36.51
0 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -71.63
5 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -71.40
10 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -70.88
15 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -70.07
20 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -68.94
25 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -67.47
30 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -65.63
35 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -63.37
40 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -60.65
45 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -57.41
50 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -53.59
55 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -49.13
60 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -43.98
65 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -38.16
70 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -31.72
75 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -24.82
80 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -17.67
85 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -10.55
90 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -3.71
95 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    2.62
100 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    8.33
105 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    13.35
110 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    17.70
115 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    21.43
120 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    24.61
125 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    27.28
130 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    29.53
135 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    31.40
140 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    32.96
145 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    34.22
150 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    35.24
155 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    36.03
160 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    36.62
165 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    37.03
170 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    37.27
175 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    37.34
180 	 30 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    37.25
0 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -72.26
5 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -72.04
10 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -71.52
15 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -70.71
20 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -69.58
25 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -68.11
30 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -66.26
35 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -64.00
40 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -61.27
45 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -58.00
50 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -54.14
55 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -49.62
60 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -44.40
65 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -38.47
70 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -31.91
75 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -24.87
80 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -17.58
85 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -10.32
90 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -3.38
95 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    3.04
100 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    8.81
105 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    13.87
110 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    18.24
115 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    21.98
120 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    25.15
125 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    27.83
130 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    30.07
135 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    31.94
140 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    33.49
145 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    34.76
150 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    35.77
155 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    36.57
160 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    37.16
165 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    37.57
170 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    37.81
175 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    37.89
180 	 35 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    37.81
0 	 40 	 -300.00     	   0.00     	    -72.77
... 159721 more lines ...
Attachment 4: XF_model_19_96.txt
freq : 83.33 MHz
SWR : 1.965000
 Theta     Phi     Gain(dB)     Gain     Phase(deg) 
0 	 0 	 -83.71     	   0.00     	    -158.06
5 	 0 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -153.75
10 	 0 	 -11.87     	   0.06     	    -148.66
15 	 0 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -144.50
20 	 0 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -140.71
25 	 0 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -136.31
30 	 0 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -131.91
35 	 0 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -127.38
40 	 0 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -123.42
45 	 0 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -119.24
50 	 0 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -115.23
55 	 0 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -111.53
60 	 0 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -107.68
65 	 0 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -104.22
70 	 0 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -100.95
75 	 0 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -97.77
80 	 0 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -94.90
85 	 0 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -92.40
90 	 0 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -89.68
95 	 0 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -87.43
100 	 0 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -85.51
105 	 0 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -84.01
110 	 0 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -82.20
115 	 0 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -80.97
120 	 0 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -79.70
125 	 0 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -78.83
130 	 0 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -77.85
135 	 0 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -77.23
140 	 0 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -77.60
145 	 0 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -77.60
150 	 0 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -78.04
155 	 0 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -78.59
160 	 0 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -79.94
165 	 0 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -81.34
170 	 0 	 -11.87     	   0.07     	    -84.60
175 	 0 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -89.05
180 	 0 	 -83.70     	   0.00     	    -95.44
0 	 5 	 -83.74     	   0.00     	    -20.42
5 	 5 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -21.56
10 	 5 	 -11.87     	   0.06     	    -22.65
15 	 5 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -23.78
20 	 5 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -24.81
25 	 5 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -25.80
30 	 5 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -26.78
35 	 5 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -27.69
40 	 5 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -28.54
45 	 5 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -29.38
50 	 5 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -30.15
55 	 5 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -30.88
60 	 5 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -31.59
65 	 5 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -32.25
70 	 5 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -32.87
75 	 5 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -33.45
80 	 5 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -33.97
85 	 5 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -34.45
90 	 5 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -34.85
95 	 5 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -35.18
100 	 5 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -35.40
105 	 5 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -35.52
110 	 5 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -35.51
115 	 5 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -35.38
120 	 5 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -35.10
125 	 5 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -34.70
130 	 5 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -34.17
135 	 5 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -33.48
140 	 5 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -32.71
145 	 5 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -31.84
150 	 5 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -30.83
155 	 5 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -29.77
160 	 5 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -28.61
165 	 5 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -27.42
170 	 5 	 -11.87     	   0.07     	    -26.17
175 	 5 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -24.90
180 	 5 	 -83.74     	   0.00     	    -23.60
0 	 10 	 -83.84     	   0.00     	    -19.91
5 	 10 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -20.98
10 	 10 	 -11.87     	   0.06     	    -22.04
15 	 10 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -23.08
20 	 10 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -24.09
25 	 10 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -25.07
30 	 10 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -26.00
35 	 10 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -26.89
40 	 10 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -27.75
45 	 10 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -28.55
50 	 10 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -29.32
55 	 10 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -30.06
60 	 10 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -30.76
65 	 10 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -31.42
70 	 10 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -32.05
75 	 10 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -32.64
80 	 10 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -33.17
85 	 10 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -33.66
90 	 10 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -34.07
95 	 10 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -34.41
100 	 10 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -34.64
105 	 10 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -34.77
110 	 10 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -34.79
115 	 10 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -34.68
120 	 10 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -34.44
125 	 10 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -34.06
130 	 10 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -33.55
135 	 10 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -32.91
140 	 10 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -32.16
145 	 10 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -31.30
150 	 10 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -30.34
155 	 10 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -29.31
160 	 10 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -28.20
165 	 10 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -27.05
170 	 10 	 -11.87     	   0.07     	    -25.86
175 	 10 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -24.64
180 	 10 	 -83.84     	   0.00     	    -23.37
0 	 15 	 -84.01     	   0.00     	    -19.75
5 	 15 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -20.78
10 	 15 	 -11.87     	   0.06     	    -21.80
15 	 15 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -22.82
20 	 15 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -23.80
25 	 15 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -24.75
30 	 15 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -25.67
35 	 15 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -26.54
40 	 15 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -27.38
45 	 15 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -28.17
50 	 15 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -28.93
55 	 15 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -29.66
60 	 15 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -30.36
65 	 15 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -31.01
70 	 15 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -31.63
75 	 15 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -32.21
80 	 15 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -32.75
85 	 15 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -33.22
90 	 15 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -33.63
95 	 15 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -33.96
100 	 15 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -34.19
105 	 15 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -34.33
110 	 15 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -34.35
115 	 15 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -34.24
120 	 15 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -34.00
125 	 15 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -33.65
130 	 15 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -33.16
135 	 15 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -32.54
140 	 15 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -31.82
145 	 15 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -30.99
150 	 15 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -30.07
155 	 15 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -29.06
160 	 15 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -28.00
165 	 15 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -26.87
170 	 15 	 -11.87     	   0.07     	    -25.71
175 	 15 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -24.52
180 	 15 	 -84.01     	   0.00     	    -23.30
0 	 20 	 -84.25     	   0.00     	    -19.66
5 	 20 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -20.66
10 	 20 	 -11.87     	   0.06     	    -21.65
15 	 20 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -22.63
20 	 20 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -23.59
25 	 20 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -24.52
30 	 20 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -25.42
35 	 20 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -26.27
40 	 20 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -27.10
45 	 20 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -27.88
50 	 20 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -28.63
55 	 20 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -29.35
60 	 20 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -30.03
65 	 20 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -30.67
70 	 20 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -31.28
75 	 20 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -31.84
80 	 20 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -32.36
85 	 20 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -32.82
90 	 20 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -33.21
95 	 20 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -33.52
100 	 20 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -33.75
105 	 20 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -33.88
110 	 20 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -33.89
115 	 20 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -33.79
120 	 20 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -33.57
125 	 20 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -33.22
130 	 20 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -32.76
135 	 20 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -32.17
140 	 20 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -31.48
145 	 20 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -30.68
150 	 20 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -29.80
155 	 20 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -28.83
160 	 20 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -27.80
165 	 20 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -26.72
170 	 20 	 -11.87     	   0.07     	    -25.60
175 	 20 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -24.44
180 	 20 	 -84.25     	   0.00     	    -23.27
0 	 25 	 -84.56     	   0.00     	    -19.61
5 	 25 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -20.56
10 	 25 	 -11.87     	   0.06     	    -21.52
15 	 25 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -22.47
20 	 25 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -23.40
25 	 25 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -24.30
30 	 25 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -25.17
35 	 25 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -26.01
40 	 25 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -26.81
45 	 25 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -27.58
50 	 25 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -28.32
55 	 25 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -29.01
60 	 25 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -29.68
65 	 25 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -30.31
70 	 25 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -30.89
75 	 25 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -31.44
80 	 25 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -31.93
85 	 25 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -32.37
90 	 25 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -32.75
95 	 25 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -33.04
100 	 25 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -33.25
105 	 25 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -33.37
110 	 25 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -33.38
115 	 25 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -33.28
120 	 25 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -33.07
125 	 25 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -32.74
130 	 25 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -32.30
135 	 25 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -31.75
140 	 25 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -31.09
145 	 25 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -30.35
150 	 25 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -29.50
155 	 25 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -28.58
160 	 25 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -27.60
165 	 25 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -26.56
170 	 25 	 -11.87     	   0.07     	    -25.49
175 	 25 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -24.38
180 	 25 	 -84.56     	   0.00     	    -23.25
0 	 30 	 -84.95     	   0.00     	    -19.57
5 	 30 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -20.48
10 	 30 	 -11.87     	   0.06     	    -21.40
15 	 30 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -22.31
20 	 30 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -23.20
25 	 30 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -24.07
30 	 30 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -24.92
35 	 30 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -25.73
40 	 30 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -26.51
45 	 30 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -27.26
50 	 30 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -27.97
55 	 30 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -28.65
60 	 30 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -29.30
65 	 30 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -29.90
70 	 30 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -30.47
75 	 30 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -30.99
80 	 30 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -31.45
85 	 30 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -31.87
90 	 30 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -32.21
95 	 30 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -32.49
100 	 30 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -32.69
105 	 30 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -32.79
110 	 30 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -32.80
115 	 30 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -32.71
120 	 30 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -32.51
125 	 30 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -32.20
130 	 30 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -31.79
135 	 30 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -31.27
140 	 30 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -30.66
145 	 30 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -29.95
150 	 30 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -29.16
155 	 30 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -28.30
160 	 30 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -27.37
165 	 30 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -26.39
170 	 30 	 -11.87     	   0.07     	    -25.36
175 	 30 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -24.31
180 	 30 	 -84.96     	   0.00     	    -23.23
0 	 35 	 -85.43     	   0.00     	    -19.55
5 	 35 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -20.41
10 	 35 	 -11.87     	   0.06     	    -21.27
15 	 35 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -22.14
20 	 35 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -22.99
25 	 35 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -23.82
30 	 35 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -24.63
35 	 35 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -25.42
40 	 35 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -26.17
45 	 35 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -26.90
50 	 35 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -27.58
55 	 35 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -28.24
60 	 35 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -28.86
65 	 35 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -29.44
70 	 35 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -29.98
75 	 35 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -30.47
80 	 35 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -30.91
85 	 35 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -31.30
90 	 35 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -31.61
95 	 35 	 3.43     	   2.20     	    -31.87
100 	 35 	 3.33     	   2.15     	    -32.05
105 	 35 	 3.15     	   2.07     	    -32.14
110 	 35 	 2.91     	   1.95     	    -32.15
115 	 35 	 2.59     	   1.81     	    -32.06
120 	 35 	 2.18     	   1.65     	    -31.88
125 	 35 	 1.69     	   1.47     	    -31.60
130 	 35 	 1.09     	   1.29     	    -31.22
135 	 35 	 0.39     	   1.09     	    -30.74
140 	 35 	 -0.45     	   0.90     	    -30.17
145 	 35 	 -1.45     	   0.72     	    -29.52
150 	 35 	 -2.66     	   0.54     	    -28.79
155 	 35 	 -4.13     	   0.39     	    -27.98
160 	 35 	 -5.97     	   0.25     	    -27.11
165 	 35 	 -8.40     	   0.14     	    -26.19
170 	 35 	 -11.87     	   0.07     	    -25.23
175 	 35 	 -17.86     	   0.02     	    -24.23
180 	 35 	 -85.44     	   0.00     	    -23.22
0 	 40 	 -86.01     	   0.00     	    -19.53
... 159721 more lines ...
Attachment 5: XF_model_29_87.txt
freq : 83.33 MHz
SWR : 1.965000
 Theta     Phi     Gain(dB)     Gain     Phase(deg) 
0 	 0 	 -77.59     	   0.00     	    -23.13
5 	 0 	 -17.30     	   0.02     	    -23.13
10 	 0 	 -11.30     	   0.07     	    -23.11
15 	 0 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -23.07
20 	 0 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -23.00
25 	 0 	 -3.56     	   0.44     	    -22.93
30 	 0 	 -2.09     	   0.62     	    -22.84
35 	 0 	 -0.89     	   0.82     	    -22.73
40 	 0 	 0.11     	   1.03     	    -22.61
45 	 0 	 0.95     	   1.24     	    -22.47
50 	 0 	 1.66     	   1.46     	    -22.33
55 	 0 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -22.17
60 	 0 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -22.01
65 	 0 	 3.14     	   2.06     	    -21.84
70 	 0 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -21.66
75 	 0 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -21.48
80 	 0 	 3.88     	   2.44     	    -21.29
85 	 0 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -21.11
90 	 0 	 4.02     	   2.52     	    -20.92
95 	 0 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -20.74
100 	 0 	 3.88     	   2.45     	    -20.55
105 	 0 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -20.38
110 	 0 	 3.47     	   2.22     	    -20.20
115 	 0 	 3.15     	   2.06     	    -20.03
120 	 0 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -19.87
125 	 0 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -19.72
130 	 0 	 1.66     	   1.47     	    -19.58
135 	 0 	 0.96     	   1.25     	    -19.44
140 	 0 	 0.12     	   1.03     	    -19.31
145 	 0 	 -0.88     	   0.82     	    -19.20
150 	 0 	 -2.08     	   0.62     	    -19.10
155 	 0 	 -3.55     	   0.44     	    -19.02
160 	 0 	 -5.39     	   0.29     	    -18.94
165 	 0 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    -18.89
170 	 0 	 -11.29     	   0.07     	    -18.84
175 	 0 	 -17.28     	   0.02     	    -18.82
180 	 0 	 -77.55     	   0.00     	    -18.81
0 	 5 	 -77.73     	   0.00     	    -18.36
5 	 5 	 -17.30     	   0.02     	    -18.44
10 	 5 	 -11.30     	   0.07     	    -18.54
15 	 5 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -18.64
20 	 5 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -18.77
25 	 5 	 -3.56     	   0.44     	    -18.92
30 	 5 	 -2.09     	   0.62     	    -19.09
35 	 5 	 -0.89     	   0.82     	    -19.27
40 	 5 	 0.11     	   1.03     	    -19.47
45 	 5 	 0.95     	   1.24     	    -19.67
50 	 5 	 1.66     	   1.46     	    -19.89
55 	 5 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -20.12
60 	 5 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -20.35
65 	 5 	 3.14     	   2.06     	    -20.60
70 	 5 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -20.84
75 	 5 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -21.08
80 	 5 	 3.88     	   2.44     	    -21.33
85 	 5 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -21.57
90 	 5 	 4.02     	   2.52     	    -21.81
95 	 5 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -22.04
100 	 5 	 3.88     	   2.45     	    -22.28
105 	 5 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -22.50
110 	 5 	 3.47     	   2.22     	    -22.72
115 	 5 	 3.15     	   2.06     	    -22.92
120 	 5 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -23.12
125 	 5 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -23.30
130 	 5 	 1.66     	   1.47     	    -23.47
135 	 5 	 0.96     	   1.25     	    -23.62
140 	 5 	 0.12     	   1.03     	    -23.75
145 	 5 	 -0.88     	   0.82     	    -23.85
150 	 5 	 -2.08     	   0.62     	    -23.94
155 	 5 	 -3.55     	   0.44     	    -24.00
160 	 5 	 -5.39     	   0.29     	    -24.04
165 	 5 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    -24.06
170 	 5 	 -11.29     	   0.07     	    -24.04
175 	 5 	 -17.28     	   0.02     	    -24.01
180 	 5 	 -77.69     	   0.00     	    -23.95
0 	 10 	 -77.94     	   0.00     	    -16.18
5 	 10 	 -17.30     	   0.02     	    -16.28
10 	 10 	 -11.30     	   0.07     	    -16.44
15 	 10 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -16.61
20 	 10 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -16.84
25 	 10 	 -3.56     	   0.44     	    -17.09
30 	 10 	 -2.09     	   0.62     	    -17.37
35 	 10 	 -0.89     	   0.82     	    -17.69
40 	 10 	 0.11     	   1.03     	    -18.03
45 	 10 	 0.95     	   1.24     	    -18.40
50 	 10 	 1.66     	   1.46     	    -18.78
55 	 10 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -19.19
60 	 10 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -19.60
65 	 10 	 3.14     	   2.06     	    -20.03
70 	 10 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -20.46
75 	 10 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -20.89
80 	 10 	 3.88     	   2.44     	    -21.33
85 	 10 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -21.76
90 	 10 	 4.02     	   2.52     	    -22.19
95 	 10 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -22.61
100 	 10 	 3.88     	   2.45     	    -23.02
105 	 10 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -23.43
110 	 10 	 3.47     	   2.22     	    -23.82
115 	 10 	 3.15     	   2.06     	    -24.20
120 	 10 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -24.55
125 	 10 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -24.88
130 	 10 	 1.66     	   1.47     	    -25.19
135 	 10 	 0.96     	   1.25     	    -25.46
140 	 10 	 0.12     	   1.03     	    -25.71
145 	 10 	 -0.88     	   0.82     	    -25.92
150 	 10 	 -2.08     	   0.62     	    -26.09
155 	 10 	 -3.55     	   0.44     	    -26.22
160 	 10 	 -5.39     	   0.29     	    -26.30
165 	 10 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    -26.35
170 	 10 	 -11.29     	   0.07     	    -26.36
175 	 10 	 -17.28     	   0.02     	    -26.33
180 	 10 	 -77.89     	   0.00     	    -26.25
0 	 15 	 -78.23     	   0.00     	    -14.91
5 	 15 	 -17.30     	   0.02     	    -15.04
10 	 15 	 -11.30     	   0.07     	    -15.22
15 	 15 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -15.44
20 	 15 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -15.71
25 	 15 	 -3.56     	   0.44     	    -16.02
30 	 15 	 -2.09     	   0.62     	    -16.37
35 	 15 	 -0.89     	   0.82     	    -16.76
40 	 15 	 0.11     	   1.03     	    -17.19
45 	 15 	 0.95     	   1.24     	    -17.64
50 	 15 	 1.66     	   1.46     	    -18.12
55 	 15 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -18.63
60 	 15 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -19.14
65 	 15 	 3.14     	   2.06     	    -19.68
70 	 15 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -20.21
75 	 15 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -20.76
80 	 15 	 3.88     	   2.44     	    -21.30
85 	 15 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -21.85
90 	 15 	 4.02     	   2.52     	    -22.39
95 	 15 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -22.92
100 	 15 	 3.88     	   2.45     	    -23.44
105 	 15 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -23.94
110 	 15 	 3.47     	   2.22     	    -24.43
115 	 15 	 3.15     	   2.06     	    -24.91
120 	 15 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -25.35
125 	 15 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -25.77
130 	 15 	 1.66     	   1.47     	    -26.16
135 	 15 	 0.96     	   1.25     	    -26.51
140 	 15 	 0.12     	   1.03     	    -26.82
145 	 15 	 -0.88     	   0.82     	    -27.09
150 	 15 	 -2.08     	   0.62     	    -27.31
155 	 15 	 -3.55     	   0.44     	    -27.48
160 	 15 	 -5.39     	   0.29     	    -27.60
165 	 15 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    -27.67
170 	 15 	 -11.29     	   0.07     	    -27.68
175 	 15 	 -17.28     	   0.02     	    -27.65
180 	 15 	 -78.17     	   0.00     	    -27.56
0 	 20 	 -78.59     	   0.00     	    -14.07
5 	 20 	 -17.30     	   0.02     	    -14.21
10 	 20 	 -11.30     	   0.07     	    -14.41
15 	 20 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -14.66
20 	 20 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -14.95
25 	 20 	 -3.56     	   0.44     	    -15.30
30 	 20 	 -2.09     	   0.62     	    -15.70
35 	 20 	 -0.89     	   0.82     	    -16.14
40 	 20 	 0.11     	   1.03     	    -16.61
45 	 20 	 0.95     	   1.24     	    -17.12
50 	 20 	 1.66     	   1.46     	    -17.66
55 	 20 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -18.23
60 	 20 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -18.82
65 	 20 	 3.14     	   2.06     	    -19.42
70 	 20 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -20.03
75 	 20 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -20.64
80 	 20 	 3.88     	   2.44     	    -21.26
85 	 20 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -21.88
90 	 20 	 4.02     	   2.52     	    -22.49
95 	 20 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -23.09
100 	 20 	 3.88     	   2.45     	    -23.69
105 	 20 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -24.26
110 	 20 	 3.47     	   2.22     	    -24.82
115 	 20 	 3.15     	   2.06     	    -25.36
120 	 20 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -25.87
125 	 20 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -26.34
130 	 20 	 1.66     	   1.47     	    -26.78
135 	 20 	 0.96     	   1.25     	    -27.18
140 	 20 	 0.12     	   1.03     	    -27.53
145 	 20 	 -0.88     	   0.82     	    -27.84
150 	 20 	 -2.08     	   0.62     	    -28.09
155 	 20 	 -3.55     	   0.44     	    -28.29
160 	 20 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -28.43
165 	 20 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    -28.52
170 	 20 	 -11.29     	   0.07     	    -28.54
175 	 20 	 -17.28     	   0.02     	    -28.51
180 	 20 	 -78.53     	   0.00     	    -28.42
0 	 25 	 -79.03     	   0.00     	    -13.47
5 	 25 	 -17.30     	   0.02     	    -13.62
10 	 25 	 -11.30     	   0.07     	    -13.83
15 	 25 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -14.09
20 	 25 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -14.41
25 	 25 	 -3.56     	   0.44     	    -14.78
30 	 25 	 -2.09     	   0.62     	    -15.20
35 	 25 	 -0.89     	   0.82     	    -15.67
40 	 25 	 0.11     	   1.03     	    -16.18
45 	 25 	 0.95     	   1.24     	    -16.73
50 	 25 	 1.66     	   1.46     	    -17.31
55 	 25 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -17.92
60 	 25 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -18.55
65 	 25 	 3.14     	   2.06     	    -19.20
70 	 25 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -19.86
75 	 25 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -20.53
80 	 25 	 3.88     	   2.44     	    -21.20
85 	 25 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -21.87
90 	 25 	 4.02     	   2.52     	    -22.54
95 	 25 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -23.20
100 	 25 	 3.88     	   2.45     	    -23.84
105 	 25 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -24.47
110 	 25 	 3.47     	   2.22     	    -25.08
115 	 25 	 3.15     	   2.06     	    -25.66
120 	 25 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -26.21
125 	 25 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -26.73
130 	 25 	 1.66     	   1.47     	    -27.21
135 	 25 	 0.96     	   1.25     	    -27.64
140 	 25 	 0.12     	   1.03     	    -28.03
145 	 25 	 -0.88     	   0.82     	    -28.36
150 	 25 	 -2.08     	   0.62     	    -28.64
155 	 25 	 -3.55     	   0.44     	    -28.86
160 	 25 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -29.02
165 	 25 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    -29.12
170 	 25 	 -11.29     	   0.07     	    -29.15
175 	 25 	 -17.28     	   0.02     	    -29.13
180 	 25 	 -78.97     	   0.00     	    -29.04
0 	 30 	 -79.57     	   0.00     	    -13.01
5 	 30 	 -17.30     	   0.02     	    -13.16
10 	 30 	 -11.30     	   0.07     	    -13.37
15 	 30 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -13.65
20 	 30 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -13.97
25 	 30 	 -3.56     	   0.44     	    -14.36
30 	 30 	 -2.09     	   0.62     	    -14.80
35 	 30 	 -0.89     	   0.82     	    -15.29
40 	 30 	 0.11     	   1.03     	    -15.82
45 	 30 	 0.95     	   1.24     	    -16.40
50 	 30 	 1.66     	   1.46     	    -17.01
55 	 30 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -17.65
60 	 30 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -18.32
65 	 30 	 3.14     	   2.06     	    -19.00
70 	 30 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -19.70
75 	 30 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -20.41
80 	 30 	 3.88     	   2.44     	    -21.12
85 	 30 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -21.84
90 	 30 	 4.02     	   2.52     	    -22.55
95 	 30 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -23.24
100 	 30 	 3.88     	   2.45     	    -23.93
105 	 30 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -24.60
110 	 30 	 3.47     	   2.22     	    -25.25
115 	 30 	 3.15     	   2.06     	    -25.87
120 	 30 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -26.46
125 	 30 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -27.01
130 	 30 	 1.66     	   1.47     	    -27.52
135 	 30 	 0.96     	   1.25     	    -27.98
140 	 30 	 0.12     	   1.03     	    -28.39
145 	 30 	 -0.88     	   0.82     	    -28.75
150 	 30 	 -2.08     	   0.62     	    -29.05
155 	 30 	 -3.55     	   0.44     	    -29.28
160 	 30 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -29.46
165 	 30 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    -29.57
170 	 30 	 -11.29     	   0.07     	    -29.61
175 	 30 	 -17.28     	   0.02     	    -29.59
180 	 30 	 -79.50     	   0.00     	    -29.50
0 	 35 	 -80.22     	   0.00     	    -12.65
5 	 35 	 -17.30     	   0.02     	    -12.80
10 	 35 	 -11.30     	   0.07     	    -13.01
15 	 35 	 -7.83     	   0.16     	    -13.28
20 	 35 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -13.62
25 	 35 	 -3.56     	   0.44     	    -14.02
30 	 35 	 -2.09     	   0.62     	    -14.47
35 	 35 	 -0.89     	   0.82     	    -14.97
40 	 35 	 0.11     	   1.03     	    -15.52
45 	 35 	 0.95     	   1.24     	    -16.11
50 	 35 	 1.66     	   1.46     	    -16.75
55 	 35 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -17.41
60 	 35 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -18.10
65 	 35 	 3.14     	   2.06     	    -18.81
70 	 35 	 3.46     	   2.22     	    -19.54
75 	 35 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -20.28
80 	 35 	 3.88     	   2.44     	    -21.03
85 	 35 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -21.78
90 	 35 	 4.02     	   2.52     	    -22.52
95 	 35 	 3.99     	   2.50     	    -23.26
100 	 35 	 3.88     	   2.45     	    -23.98
105 	 35 	 3.71     	   2.35     	    -24.68
110 	 35 	 3.47     	   2.22     	    -25.36
115 	 35 	 3.15     	   2.06     	    -26.02
120 	 35 	 2.74     	   1.88     	    -26.63
125 	 35 	 2.25     	   1.68     	    -27.21
130 	 35 	 1.66     	   1.47     	    -27.75
135 	 35 	 0.96     	   1.25     	    -28.23
140 	 35 	 0.12     	   1.03     	    -28.66
145 	 35 	 -0.88     	   0.82     	    -29.04
150 	 35 	 -2.08     	   0.62     	    -29.36
155 	 35 	 -3.55     	   0.44     	    -29.61
160 	 35 	 -5.40     	   0.29     	    -29.80
165 	 35 	 -7.82     	   0.17     	    -29.92
170 	 35 	 -11.29     	   0.07     	    -29.97
175 	 35 	 -17.28     	   0.02     	    -29.96
180 	 35 	 -80.14     	   0.00     	    -29.87
0 	 40 	 -80.99     	   0.00     	    -12.34
... 159721 more lines ...
  188   Fri Dec 30 01:16:52 2022 Alex MRun Details: 2022_12_29

We began a new run of the curved sided GA. Previously, we conducted a run just like this in July of 2022 (titled 2022_07_15_Latest_Greatest). In that run, we made substantial updates to the loop, including using the latest version of AraSim. However, we discovered after the run (which had a very flat fitness score growth curve) that we had not modified AraSim to take in gainfiles appropriately (so it was just evaluating the ARA bicone repeatedly). We've fixed this issue and a few more (see the github repository for the issues that exist and have been resolved) and are redoing this run. The run details will look much the same as that one and are visible in the attached file. Here is the location of the directory where the data for this run will be stored: /fs/ess/PAS1960/BiconeEvolutionOSC/BiconeEvolution/current_antenna_evo_build/XF_Loop/Evolutionary_Loop/Run_Outputs/2022_12_29

For a list of changes made in this run compared to previous ones, see this ELOG post on the previous run: http://radiorm.physics.ohio-state.edu/elog/GENETIS/186

Attachment 1: run_details.txt
####### VARIABLES: LINES TO CHECK OVER WHEN STARTING A NEW RUN ###############################################################################################
RunName='2022_12_29'	## This is the name of the run. You need to make a unique name each time you run.
TotalGens=100			## number of generations (after initial) to run through
NPOP=100				## number of individuals per generation; please keep this value below 99
Seeds=5			## This is how many AraSim jobs will run for each individual## the number frequencies being iterated over in XF (Currectly only affects the output.xmacro loop)
FREQ=60				## the number frequencies being iterated over in XF (Currectly only affects the output.xmacro loop)
NNT=60000			## Number of Neutrinos Thrown in AraSim   
exp=18				## exponent of the energy for the neutrinos in AraSim
ScaleFactor=1.0			## ScaleFactor used when punishing fitness scores of antennae larger than the drilling holes
GeoFactor=1			## This is the number by which we are scaling DOWN our antennas. This is passed to many files
num_keys=4			## how many XF keys we are letting this run use
database_flag=0			## 0 if not using the database, 1 if using the database
				## These next 3 define the symmetry of the cones.
RADIUS=1			## If 1, radius is asymmetric. If 0, radius is symmetric		
LENGTH=1			## If 1, length is asymmetric. If 0, length is symmetric
ANGLE=1				## If 1, angle is asymmetric. If 0, angle is symmetric
CURVED=1			## If 1, evolve curved sides. If 0, sides are straight
A=1				## If 1, A is asymmetric
B=1				## If 1, B is asymmetric
SEPARATION=0    		## If 1, separation evolves. If 0, separation is constant
NSECTIONS=2 			## The number of chromosomes
DEBUG_MODE=0			## 1 for testing (ex: send specific seeds), 0 for real runs
				## These next variables are the values passed to the GA
REPRODUCTION=0			## Number (not fraction!) of individuals formed through reproduction
CROSSOVER=96			## Number (not fraction!) of individuals formed through crossover
MUTATION=25			## Probability of mutation (divided by 100)
SIGMA=6				## Standard deviation for the mutation operation (divided by 100)
ROULETTE=2			## Percent of individuals selected through roulette (divided by 10)
TOURNAMENT=2			## Percent of individuals selected through tournament (divided by 10)
RANK=6				## Percent of individuals selected through rank (divided by 10)
ELITE=0				## Elite function on/off (1/0)

#####################################################################################################################################################
  187   Mon Dec 5 17:46:40 2022 Dylan WellsConstraints on PUEO evolved antennas

Variables of Evolved Antennas

Wall variables:
S -- length of bottom of the walls
m -- slope of the walls (currently set to 1)
H -- height of walls
x0, y0, z0 -- 3D coordinates of the bottom of the ridge
xf, yf, zf -- 3D coordinates of the top of the ridge
Beta -- curvature of the ridge

 

Antenna Walls

S is half the side length of the bottom wall
m is the slope of the outer wall
H is the max height of the outer wall

Current Constraints:

S < 50cm
H < 50cm
m = 1

Antenna Ridges

x_0, y_0, z_0 are the innitial points of the inner most part of the ridge
x_f, y_f, z_f are the final points of the inner most part of the ridge
tau is the parametric time range beta is the slope of the curve of the ridge

Current Constraints:

tau = 0.26
x_f = S
0 < x_0 <= x_f
0 < y_0 <= x_0
0 < y_f < z_f
z_0 = 0
0 < z_f <= H
(4/30) * z_f < beta < 7 * z_f (for z_f in meters, designs will 'compile' in xfdtd above this upper limit, but the curve is functionally a line for all values greater)

  186   Mon Nov 28 10:44:27 2022 Alex MRun Details Latest_Greatest_2022_11_26

Here are the changes that have been made in this (and the preceding) run relative to what we have been doing before.

  1. The newest version of AraSim has been implemented.
    1. This was done because AraSim has gone through significant changes since 2019 that make it more accurate and makes it run faster.
  2. The minimum length has been decreased to 10 cm per side.
    1. This was done because we previously tested shorter lengths for a response to the reviewer when we submitting the paper to Phys Rev D. Previously, we thought that going below 37.5 cm would lead to unreliable results, but we are reassured that that is not the case now.
  3. The GA is recording the parents and operators used to generate individuals.
    1. This should allow us to look back and make a "history" of the evolution by seeing where genes come from in each generation.
  4. The number of individuals has been increased to 100 per generation.
    1. Ryan demonstrated that a higher number of individuals does lead to a substantial improvement in the speed at which the evolution converges. 
      1. We previously thought that it did not make a big difference. However, that was done by measuring the average maximum fitness score. If we measure how many generations it takes for the evolution to reach a benchmark score, we find that more individuals helps significantly.
  5. The number of neutrinos per individual has been increased to 600k.
    1. This was done to make the fitness scores more precise. At 300k neutrinos, we expect an error of around 0.2. This will cut things down closer to 0.1, which may help us decrease the number of outlier measurements without increasing run time too much because of the AraSim speed up.

This run may take longer than previous runs due to the increased number of individuals. There may need to be modifications made to resolve or work around AraSim errors that delay the loop (due to the auto-resubmit function). Find the details of the run attached.

Attachment 1: run_details_2022_11_26.txt
####### VARIABLES: LINES TO CHECK OVER WHEN STARTING A NEW RUN ###############################################################################################
RunName='2022_11_26_Latest_Greatest'	## This is the name of the run. You need to make a unique name each time you run.
TotalGens=100			## number of generations (after initial) to run through
NPOP=100				## number of individuals per generation; please keep this value below 99
Seeds=5			## This is how many AraSim jobs will run for each individual## the number frequencies being iterated over in XF (Currectly only affects the output.xmacro loop)
FREQ=60				## the number frequencies being iterated over in XF (Currectly only affects the output.xmacro loop)
NNT=120000			## Number of Neutrinos Thrown in AraSim   
exp=18				## exponent of the energy for the neutrinos in AraSim
ScaleFactor=1.0			## ScaleFactor used when punishing fitness scores of antennae larger than the drilling holes
GeoFactor=1			## This is the number by which we are scaling DOWN our antennas. This is passed to many files
num_keys=4			## how many XF keys we are letting this run use
database_flag=0			## 0 if not using the database, 1 if using the database
				## These next 3 define the symmetry of the cones.
RADIUS=1			## If 1, radius is asymmetric. If 0, radius is symmetric		
LENGTH=1			## If 1, length is asymmetric. If 0, length is symmetric
ANGLE=1				## If 1, angle is asymmetric. If 0, angle is symmetric
CURVED=1			## If 1, evolve curved sides. If 0, sides are straight
A=1				## If 1, A is asymmetric
B=1				## If 1, B is asymmetric
SEPARATION=0    		## If 1, separation evolves. If 0, separation is constant
NSECTIONS=2 			## The number of chromosomes
DEBUG_MODE=0			## 1 for testing (ex: send specific seeds), 0 for real runs
				## These next variables are the values passed to the GA
REPRODUCTION=0			## Number (not fraction!) of individuals formed through reproduction
CROSSOVER=96			## Number (not fraction!) of individuals formed through crossover
MUTATION=4			## Probability of mutation (divided by 100)
SIGMA=6				## Standard deviation for the mutation operation (divided by 100)
ROULETTE=2			## Percent of individuals selected through roulette (divided by 10)
TOURNAMENT=2			## Percent of individuals selected through tournament (divided by 10)
RANK=6				## Percent of individuals selected through rank (divided by 10)
ELITE=0				## Elite function on/off (1/0)

#####################################################################################################################################################
  185   Thu Nov 10 10:42:20 2022 Ryan DeboltOptimizations

This is the plot for the run type that had the best performance in the most recent optimization run that was completed. The most optimized runs from these collections are decided by which run types achieve a chi-squared value of 0.1 in the fewest generations (correlating to about a 0.9 fitness score). However, the genetic algorithm does not use Chi-squared directly, instead trying to maximize the fitness score (which uses a chi-squared in the denominator) that simulates the error we see in arasim. This fitness score is usually maximized at 1.0 but the simulated error can push the score slightly beyond this. This test was conducted with a simulated error of 0.1. This optimization holds the selection methods steady at 2 tournament 2 roulette and 6 rank selected individuals per 10 selection events. The changing parameter values are in the amounts of Reproduction, Crossover, Immigration, and mutation (rate and width) that the GA performs each generation. Each generation uses 100 individuals. In the graph below, the dotted lines are the minimum Chi^2 values at each generation, solid lines are the maximum fitness score. Each color represents a different run using the same parameters and dotted and solid lines sharing the same color represent the same run. The prevailing trend in the tests leading up to this test has been that the most optimized runs have low amounts of reproduction, high amounts of crossover, and they have been pushing the boundaries of the mutation rate and gaussian width of those mutations and this run follows that trend. The ranges of values we tested over were 0-12R, 88-100C, 15-25M_Rate, and 3-7 sigma, up from the previous test. This run took an average of 16.8 +/- 11.9 generations to reach the 0.1 chi-squared benchmark, the next closest run took 20.3 +/- 10.9 generations to reach the same point, while the most optimized run from an earlier test came in as the 10th best run taking 21.9 +/- 14.4 generations. The graph shows the behavior of this by showing large improvements in early generations that tend to quickly plateau around the maximum value before oscillating around the peak it reaches. Oscillations could be caused by either small mutations around our answer and displacement from the simulated error. The Chi-squared values show a much smoother behavior with smaller oscillations at the end of the run, which helps demonstrate the impact of the error on the behavior.

Attachment 1: Plot0_96_25_6.png
Plot0_96_25_6.png
  184   Mon Oct 24 17:44:51 2022 Ryan DeboltIcemc inputs

Here is our current assumption of the antenna angles needed for the icemc inputs. 

Attachment 1: 261D6FA3-5612-412F-80FA-8AD961F7331A.jpeg
261D6FA3-5612-412F-80FA-8AD961F7331A.jpeg
ELOG V3.1.5-fc6679b